Originally posted by screwdriver222 Forgive me if i am wrong but isn't a 85mm lens on 35mm film still an 85mm lens on APS. The difference only being the cameras APS sensor only captures a cropped portion of the image. The cropped image appears 1.5 times larger. So should we still use a 85mm lens but stand further back?
Please correct me if am wrong, i am only trying to learn like everone else.
Regards Jeff
You certainly could, but it would give a different effect than using a 55mm on an APS-C camera and standing in the same place that you would with an 85mm on a full frame. The key is the amount of perspective distortion, or foreshortening that occurs.
Perspective is determined by one thing and one thing only, where you stand in relation to your subject. Focal length has no effect on it, it's just that shorter focal lengths allow you to stand closer while framing the same subject, while longer focal lengths force you to stand further back.
To illustrate, imagine this scenario: Let's say I'm shooting a portrait with my PZ-1p and an FA* 85mm. I want to get a head and shoulders shot of my subject, so I turn the camera in vertical orientation and stand about 6 feet from my subject and take the shot. Now I decided I want to create the exact same image on my K20d. I take the FA* 85 off my film body and put it on my digital body. Because I am in the same position, the perspective will be the same, but there's just one problem, I'm now chopping off my subject's head. If I back up, I can get my subject completely in the frame again, but the perspective will change. The face will flatten a bit, but the ears will look a bit larger in relation.
If I really want to create the exact same image, I need to maintain my position but switch to a lens that counteracts the camera's crop factor like the DA* 55. In fact, I believe that's why that lens was designed, to replicate the perspective and field of view of a classic portrait lens. It's the same with the DA* 50-135, it
roughly mimics the FA* 80-200.
Now that's not to say that 85mm is a
bad focal length for portraits on an APS-C system, it's just that your subjects start to flatten out a bit. To carry the example further, imagine shooting an 85mm lens on the Q, your subjects would start to look very 2-dimensional, [Edit: because you'd be forced to stand WAY back.]