Originally posted by Davidparis There is no such lens which will meet your apparent expectations. Morbid, pin-drop silence in a lens except perhaps in the very best manual lenses simply do not grace the face of the Earth. A Pentax DC-motor lens's noise as compared to a Pentax screwdrive is vastly superior in noise level, accuracy, rapidity and general satisfaction. Can't tell if your 18-135 has a problem, but adjusting expectations from dead or near silent to "enormous improvement" over screwdrives would put things in better perspective. The DC-equipped lenses definitely hum and purr briefly before AF lock-on, it's quick, it sounds right and it's reassuring.
If you could find a Pentax retailer to whom you could show/demo the lens, he's be able to confirm if there's a problem or not.
Well, naturally if everyone and their mother says "It's silent" I would assume that means in the literal sense and furthermore that any absence of silence (noise) would mean something has gone wrong. Guess we all know what assumptions make of us
. Anyway I'm not concerned if it makes an acceptable amount of noise or not, I just want to make sure I quickly contact the seller for a refund/exchange within the return period rather than assume (there's that word again) that it's normal only to find it's not the case and I wind up with a $300 paperweight.
Anyway, @Adam I can't really hear much in the video you linked with all the background noise, so I recorded my own camera for a few seconds, figure it's easier for someone else to hear it and tell me that's what they hear than to try and describe it. Here's a quick
audio clip, first few seconds is a SMC Pentax-F 35-70mm (older, loud AF), followed by the 18-135mm WR, then followed by a camera shutter noise from the K50 for good measure to use as a baseline. Mic was about 6 inches from the camera body and tuned just low enough to not have significant background noise. If there's no troubling volume or other noises in it then great I won't have to worry about it, but better safe then sorry!