Great! Keep in mind it also depends on how much stage you want to grab. Sounds like you would be better off with the 35 to be close in and still grab the whole band but if you ever wanted a head shot you would have to be really close with it!
These pix were shot with my Pentax DA 18-85 and maybe the perspective will help.
This one is at 48mm 1/25 at f4.5 (it was our bass players 60th birthday so he was a bit wacky that night)
This one is from the same distance from the stage but 10 paces to the shooters right at 75mm 1/25 at f5.6
Don't know if that's worth anything to you. I do mostly video with my cameras at gigs so not too many shots and these were taken but a fan I trust with my camera.