Welcome to the Pentax Forums!
Questions...
- When you have the aperture ring off the "A" position, does the lens stay wide open regardless of aperture ring position?
- What happens when attempting shutter priority?
If shutter priority works and the lens stays wide open at all settings (both are expected since P mode works), the problem might be the mechanical meter coupling between the lens and body (not the same as the aperture actuator.) If either of the members are missing or misaligned, the mechanism meters as if the lens were at minimum aperture. The result is that it takes a large amount of light to get any meter response.
Below is an image lifted from Dimitrov's excellent K-mount Web site. It shows the coupler on both body and lens sides of the mount (labeled "stop down coupler" and "stop down indicator" respectively):
Original location: Features and Operation of the Original K-Mount
Visually inspect both the "coupler" and the "indicator" for damage and alignment. If possible, compare both to a known good K-mount body and lens. Until physical damage has been ruled out, care should be taken to not mount the body with another lens. The same is true for the lens and another body.
If the two do not properly engage, permanent damage may be done to another body or lens if mounted.
If neither shows obvious damage, the problem may be with the electrical connections between the "coupler" and the meter. You may be able to test this with lens off and the shutter speed dial at 1/125s (emulates manual mode). You should be able to move the "coupler" through its range with your finger nail. The meter indicator should respond to the movement of the couple.
I hope this helps.
Steve