Originally posted by Coloradoblue Thank you. What do you suggest?
Both of those lenses would work, you would just get less and less of the milky way the longer the focal length. 50mm would be a pretty tight crop, especially on APS-C. You would also have less and less time to expose before seeing trailing stars, which is not good for the milky way. So, a wider lens gives you exposure advantages as well as composure advantages.
Here are two of my own examples comparing a 24mm and 14mm lens on my full-frame Pentax K-1. Remember, an APS-C camera is going to further crop the image, so my personal opinion for something so big like the milky way on APS-C would be to shoot for an ultra wide lens.
Rokinon 24mm On K-1:
Rokinon 14mm On K-1:
Have so much fun. I just started too, and there is lots to learn. Read a lot, watch a lot, and ask questions