Originally posted by stevebrot Are you using FocusTune along with the LensAlign? I use a different method,* but LensAlign + FocusTune would be my first choice of the commercial offerings, primarily because the software evaluates scatter before suggesting an adjustment.
FWIW, the manufacturer suggests a range of 1.9m - 3.8m target distance, using the distance tool at
LensAlign.
As for your hit ratio, it will improve as you back away from evaluating at 100% and reading distance. After all, the classic DOF calculations are based on an 8"x10" print viewed at 12". As for the target not being "still", if you are shooting hand-held, neither is the photographer. The combination of distance shifts works against a quantitative approach to excellence.
BTW...MFA is Canon-speak. In Pentaxland, we talk about AF fine adjustment.
Steve
* Flat resolution target, natural light (north-facing window), 10X focal length, 20 repetitions, center AF point, recording the direction to correct in 100% live view. If about half correct near and about half correct far, no fine adjustment is needed. A bias one way or the other signals a try at improving by adjusting one step at a time. Once the distribution evens out, I field test using the center AF point, knowing that the other AF points will use the same correction factor, even though a calibration of the optical field using the f/5.6 sensor at that point may indicate a different correction. This possibility I choose to ignore.
yes focustune+lensalign, I moved in closer at 3m, but get about the same results. Agree on the movement from both subject and photographer, that's why I count the inside results more, since it is a still target.
I would agree that looking at further distance on print size would make many more shots in focus; unfortunately the way I send files to others is often digital, and even a 2x2 downscale (6mp) isn't enough to salvage unless the focus is pretty perfect. it's hard to explain to a layperson who could be getting results from colleagues with MILC bodies with pinpoint focus with much better hitrates.
MFA not sure is manufacturer specific, at least I don't think. Canon world would be AFMA.