Okay, here is a little update:
I found an
original Asahi M39-M42 Adapter on eBay and received it today. I also bought a few more M39 SLR mount lenses, a Zenit 3M and a Zenit 3 in the meantime. One of the M39 lenses, a Jupiter-11 135mm f/4, also came with one of these
black generic M39-M42 adapters. The other lenses are a Mir-1 37mm f/2.8 and a Helios 44 58mm f/2.
Here is what I found out, and I hope that this will counter some of the misinformation that circulates on here and around the internet about these
three different thread mounts. All of the following, if not explicitly stated otherwise, is tested first-hand experience and can be easily confirmed, so it is
not just speculation.
- M42 (the Mount the Spotmatic uses) has a flange focal distance of 45.5mm
- M39 LTM (LTM = "Leica Thread Mount", which is the Leica rangefinder standard) has a flange focal distance of 28.8mm
- M39 SLR (sometimes also called "M39 Zenit" - basically the soviets took the M39 LTM mount and moved it to the front to make place for the mirror of the Zenit cameras) has a flange focal distance of 45.2mm
The lens mounts of all of my lenses I listed above are M39 SLR. As far as I can tell, variants of them were built for either M39 LTM or M42, or both, as well.
Here is an example of the Jupiter-11 135mm both in M39 LTM and M39 SLR. The version I have is the one to the right, and as you can see, the LTM version has a longer tube at the rear to compensate for the shorter flange focus distance of the LTM mount.
You can put LTM lenses on Zenit bodies and vice versa, but obviously the focus would be way off:
- Putting an LTM lens on a Zenit body would basically be like using the lens with a Macro Extension Tube.
- Putting a Zenit lens on a LTM body would work exactly opposite. (I don't have any LTM lenses so I can't test how much off it is, but I assume that focusing would not be possible at all because all focusing distances would be "behind infinity".)
The Asahi Adapter I bought is labelled as "Asahi Leica Mount Adaptor A" and the original packaging which was included with the adapter I bought says this on it:
Quote: "For use of Leica mount Lenses on the PENTAX camera body (close-ups only)"
This is a bit misleading, as it is also usable with M39 SLR lenses, and even better so in my opinion. Since the difference between LTM lenses and M42 is 16.7mm, and between M39 SLR lenses and M42 it is only 0.3mm, it is like a much smaller macro extension tube, and the "close-up only" property of it is much less severe.
This Asahi adapter (obviously) fits nicely onto the Spotmatic, focusing for example with the Jupiter-9 85mm works up to about 4m, so for portrait photography it works really well.
I also have a digital camera (Sony) and both a Fotga M42 adapter and a Metabones EF adapter for it.
Both of them (for the Metabones I used a M42-EF Adapter ring) result in about the same focusing range like with the Spotmatic.
When used with an M42 lens like any of my Takumars, focusing to infinity works perfectly, confirming the adapters maintaining the correct flange distance.
Interestingly, the black, generic adapters are way less off. Using the M39 SLR lenses with one of these adapter rings and one of the two ways I have to put them on the Sony,
focusing to infinity almost works.
There is a significant difference between the original Asahi adapter and the generic black ones concerning flange distance, which makes sense since the Asahi one was not made with M39 SLR lenses in mind.
Using any of the adapter combinations on my Sony but with the black M39-M42 adapter instead of the Asahi one, I can focus on buildings approximately 100m away without problems, and when stopped down, even much further than that.
This potentially also explains, why these black adapters don't fit onto the Spotmatic; it was not made to accommodate the deeper adapter which is needed to get the lens closer to the film plane.
I don't know if they fit on other M42 cameras, but there are other people who had similar issues, for example
here with a Pentax M42-K adapter.
In conclusion:
- M39 LTM and M39 Zenit is not the same.
- A lot of the soviet lenses available were made for both mounts, which adds to the confusion.
- There is a genuine Asahi M39-M42 adapter, but it can only be used for focusing on close distances when using M39 SLR lenses (
very close distances when using LTM lenses).
- The more modern black generic M39-M42 adapter rings enable focusing to far distances, but do not fit on all M42 bodies/adapters out there, the Spotmatic and Pentax M42-K adapter being two examples.