Originally posted by huxley75 What would you recommend I get to replace the JC Penney 1:3.5f=80-200mm lens? Since the 49mm and 50mm are prime lenses, what should I get as a good, all-around lens for general use?
It's hard to tell whether the JC Penney lens is bad enough to immediately replace. Someone made it for them, and that maker might have done a decent job. Tokina made a huge zoom with those specs for Soligor which was pretty good. If you find a reason to hate it, here are some ideas:
Vivitar Series 1 70-210mm f3.5 Macro - the serial number should start with 22, though some people like the 37xxxxxx ones.
SMC Pentax-A 70-210mm f4 - this will be more expensive because it is more useful on Pentax DSLRs, though the extra features do nothing for you on your film camera. It's more compact than the Vivitar. It might be useful when you upgrade your DSLR to Pentax.
There are a lot of zooms in the 35-70 or 28-80 range that were intended to replace the 50mm standard lenses. None of them are that fast. I have an SMC Pentax-A 35-70mm f4 that I really like the construction of. On my film camera I used a Sigma 35-70mm f3.5-4.5 Zoommaster something, without noticing any problems with it. Since switching to digital, I tend to ignore zooms in this range, so I have no other suggestions.