Originally posted by AdamJ The images look great, but after spending more time with the new RAW-based noise reduction/sharpening in LR3b2 (and ACR6) I have found almost no need to use 3rd party de-noise software.
I've spent time going back through my catalog at some of my very noisy images and by tweaking the LR3b2 denoising - I cannot seem to make any improvement with 3rd party tools...
I would be curious how well I (or someone else) could process these images using just LR3b2 and fine-tuning the denoise and sharpening settings.
One of the biggest reasons for 3'rd party processing over the ACR6 and LR3 RAW engine is where banding and luminance noise management comes into the picture(<- haha). Hrm... and though the new Adobe engine is quite possibly the best RAW color NR engine to date, it doesn't seem to do as good a job as Topaz Denoise 4 with some of the tougher luminance noise areas within a scene(see cat's eye in shadow).
Also... I've found Denoise 4 to be very good at OOF NR processing as well. A task that seemed only possible with Noiseware Pro up to this point. However... I have yet to try TDN4 in circumstances where low frequency noise is an issue(yellow blotching), which is quite possibly the worst possible noise scenario to tackle with high ISO image processing.
Unfortunately... the old model seems to stick.
As it stands, it seems like every tool has it strength and weakness, and the notion of a one size fits all noise management solution does yet seem upon us.
Having said all that... if Adobe ever sets its sights on Photoshop's own embedded noise management system, they may very well put an end to this fiasco