Originally posted by climit However good high Iso capabilities become, they always greatly reduce IQ. So base Iso is preferable.
Well said. High ISO is and always will be a trade off, no matter how much Pentax tries to make it the new pissing contest after megapixels.
ISO is only one small part of the equation, and has anyone stopped to wonder what an also-ran the K-5 might be otherwise?
Also high ISO, grain/noise, happens to be an valid artistic factor available to the photographer to exploit, so rushing into forgoing it by clever in-cam processing is really only giving away creative ground. Surely.
OK, so better night (low light) cameras have their place too. No panacea though.
But let's not overlook that it's Pentax here, and mainly its fanbois beating chests over this single standout item, all the other mfgrs seem to be content to go their own different ways.
For said fanbois: I remain unconvinced that Sony and Nikon for example, could not have easily wiped the floor in the ISO stakes with their recent equivalent offerings,
if they had wanted to.
Likewise Canon took a big divergence with its new this year 60D, a path that many people simply don't understand, and slag off at them over the so-called 'downgrade' model.
The answer there is that deeper pockets translates to more power, the power to respond to and drive mass market trends and desires that only big picture market research exposes.
This also leaves Canon and Nikon to always be able to keep lower in price tags against the K-5 in shops. That matters too.
You do not win with a better mousetrap. You win with the
right mousetrap.
Just like Hoya/Pentax, it all about the tangents pursued. And clearly both Canon and Nikon
chose to pull
very heavily toward hi-cap video functionality and usability, something that geeks are blase about.
OK, so now let's wait and see who sells the most cameras through the coming year!
And will those non Pentax buyers miss not having the biggest ISO? I doubt it.
No one really cares what camera took that
great picture.
That's reality. Thanks for listening, you may plug yourself back in now.
[Psst, there's a separate forum section for lenses, with some good cud-chewing on the new 35/budget in there too.]
.R.