Originally posted by Rusty Yes, but he used the E-510 optimum settings and the K10D default settings:
Olympus E-510 (NF Off) vs. Pentax K10D
Camera settings:
* Olympus E-510: Olympus 50 mm F2.0 lens, Aperture Priority, ISO 100
JPEG Large/SHQ, Manual WB, Noise Filter Off, Sharpness -2, Anti-shock 2 sec
* Pentax K10D: Pentax 50 mm F1.4 lens, Aperture Priority, ISO 100
JPEG Large/Fine, Manual WB, Default Parameters (Natural IS), Self-Timer (auto MLU)
I hardly call that a fair comparison
Rusty
Yup, I'm aware that he didn't play around with the K10D's settings, and that's hardly fair, but I would think that the focus is and should be on the E-510, at least in that review. As well, it would be overly tedious to do mix and match comparisons between the E-510 default and ideal settings and the competition's default and ideal settings.
Just the fact that Simon Joinson played with the E-510's settings makes me wish that he would review the upcoming cameras from Pentax.
Suffice to say that Phil didn't give the K10D a more thorough test, but then that's his style in reviewing, anyway: all cameras tested using default settings.
DCResource used to muck around with a camera's settings when they do their review, but it doesn't seem like they don't anymore.
The best bet for Pentax cameras to be given a fair and thorough test is to have someone do a site specifically for everything Pentax, much like what Wrotniak does for
Olympus, which, by the way, is a good read for a lot of things Olympus. He's fair and balanced with his articles.