Originally posted by Lowell Goudge Food for thought. when you say for portrait mode the focus point is in the center of the focus range, this means the camera front focuses, because depth of field in terms of distance is 1/3 in front 2/3 behind the pointof critical focus.
are we really talking about a deliberate setting here?
OK - here goes major speculation:
When the camera is in some "specific" mode - I am using landscape - portrait - and macro - those modes make assumptions as to what the user wants in focus. Since you have told the camera - by picking a mode or in the P or Green functions - the camera is assuming that you want certain portions of the image to be emphasised.
Now I was raised during a time when images had three basic parts - forground - middle ground and background. When using these "modes" the camera is emphasising a certain 'ground' to be the area of interest. e.g.
Macro -- forground in focus - the edge of the middle ground is the focus point - so AF (since it knows the f:stop) tends to FF - thereby throwing the background OOF and at the rear edge of DOF.
Portrait -- forground not all that important - background OOF. AF knowns the subject needs DOF to be dead center at the focal point - so the AF system sets the focus to maximize the DOF at the focal point.
Landscape -- background is the primary subject - forground to be ignored - middle ground less so. AF subsystem moves the focus to have the DOF contain all of the background.
All of this would be easier to visuallize if the d*mn lenses had DOF scales on them. I used to do this on purpose when shooting with my manual 35mm SLR. I think it is interesting to note that all of the so called "test" images I have seen are shot with wide open lenses where the DOF is a few millimeters.
Now let me be clear - this is mostly speculation on my part - as I do not measurebate - nor do I shoot "modes" anymore. I did that for the first week or so with my *ist Ds - within 6 months I was shooting 99.999% in AV, with a de-coupled AF (OK on the *ist Ds) and using RAW. When I started reading about BF/FF I took a look and could not see a problem with my camera. When I got my K10D, the same thing - in fact it has never had its shutter tripped in "Green" mode. I am not bragging - it is just something I do not use - I am the photographer - I want to be in control.
The Elitist - formerly known as PDL