Originally posted by bossa I didn't like that scene.. very Un-Doctorish if you ask me. Then again Tennant overacted and was too 'tough guy' in that scene.. ..but it was his 1st day on the job so...
Nothing against Matt Smith, but once he's gone he's gone. He's good enough but he's just not a Doctor I can love, and I've honestly tried. Doc 10 will live in my heart and on my screen forever. I'm a 5/10 Whovian. 5 was my first Doc and I still love Peter Davison's Doctor before any other classic one, but Tennant was THE Doctor for me absolutely. (It tickles me that that the two are now related by marriage.) Excepting the Timeflight CIN bit with both of them which was too, too awesome my favorite scene in all of his tenure was this one actually. Alas, video of it is not available now or I'd post it for all to see...
The Doctor:You know what? I really liked Anita. She was brave, even when she was crying. And she never gave in. And you ate her. But I'm going to let that pass. Just as long as you let them pass.
Vashta Nerada: How long have you known?
The Doctor: I counted the shadows. You only have one now.
The Vashta Nerade advance, slowly....
The Doctor: Don't play games with me. You just killed someone I liked. That is not a safe place to stand. I'm The Doctor and you're in the biggest library in the Universe. (Long, long pause....) LOOK ME UP....
The Vashta Nerada do so then duly and sensibly retreat....
I think Tennant was absolutely born to play The Doctor. As for overacting what actor playing The Doctor didn't overact at times? Dr Who isn't exactly Shakespeare quality material. It's a kid's show. Overacting is part of the character at times. Matt Smith does it all the time actually, cough. The only person I've seen recently who I think just might outclass Tennant would be Benedict Cumberbatch. Him I would KILL to see in the Tardis, as either The Doctor or maybe The Master but alas, I think that's less likely than a FF Pentax.
We just might be getting multiple Doctors for the anniversary next year though. Tennant is hinting hard that his alternate Doc will make an appearance with or without Rose and Paul McGann said something rather mysterious about doors still being open for the 50th too. If we actually get Smith, Tennant, and McGann on a story for the anniversary I am going to be so, so happy!!! Eccleston probably won't touch it given the way his tenure ended and his stated reluctance to revisit the role on screen, but I'd dearly love it if we could have The 4 Doctors. Three will do though so long as two of them are Tennant and McGann. I really want McGann even more than Tennant actually. I thought the movie was lame but I liked his 8th Doctor a lot and I always wanted to see him back in the role on screen. He's fabulous in the audios as 8....
But Tennant? He's a Whovian God in so far as I am concerned. I'd cheerfully put his face on a T-shirt and wear it anytime, and for the record I just don't do that, offer to put someone's face on my chest as a major fan thing. Too tacky, but I'd make an exception for THIS guy....(Smooch...)