Originally posted by mattdm It doesn't seem to change the P mode setting, but rather changes the weighting of shutter speed vs. aperture. So if you turn it one way, you get fast shutter speeds and wide apertures. The other direction goes towards the other possibility: slower shutter speed matched with greater depth of field. The green button then puts you back to whatever the base program would select. (MTF in my current.)
So, like wasupdoc says, it seems to give you exactly what you'd get with both Tv or Av mode, but with only one dial.
Matt,
Color me dense, but I still don't follow. And I'd be grateful for a better understanding of what's at issue here. As I said, perhaps I don't understand the whole program line/program shift idea, so let me start there, and somebody can slap me and set me straight if I've got this wrong.
The way I understand program line, it tells the camera to give weight to one setting or another when calculating an automatic exposure. So if you set the camera to use the depth (of field) program line, then when it meters the light and calculates appropriate exposure settings, it goes for a small aperture insofar as possible. On the other hand, if you select shutter speed priority as the program line, then the camera tries to give you the fastest (reasonable) shutter speed and depth of field be damned. If you select MTF, the camera consults its internal database for the lens and finds that this lens works best at, oh, f/5.6, so it tries to get the exposure close to f/5.6 and calculates the shutter speed accordingly. There must be some limits in there and I assume they're reasonable. For example, perhaps the internal computer won't ever set the the shutter speed to something slower than the reciprocal of the focal length. But I think I've got the general idea right. Yes?
By the way, I have NO earthly idea what the camera does in "Normal" mode. Maybe it's Goldilocks mode: aperture as close to f/5.6 or f/8 as possible, shutter speed as close to 1/400th sec as possible. But I dunno. Since I've been shooting in M mode almost exclusively for a year, I haven't really given a darn about program line until today when I read your message.
__________
OK, if I'm completely off base, it should be evident by now. If I'm not, keep reading.
So I take "P (program line) Shift" to be a way of shifting, i.e. changing the program line, from an e-dial, so you don't have to dig into the custom menus to do this. BUT, you can only push the e-dial in two directions, and there are at least THREE program lines to get to (shutter speed, depth of field, and MTF, assuming that we simply skip "Normal"). That's why I was thinking, when I first read your message, that you could turn the e-dial and tell the camera, "No, I don't want you to meter the scene and set the camera using depth of field program line, I want you to give greater weight to the shutter speed," and the camera would do two things:
- Change the settings from, say, f/8 and 1/200th sec, to f/5.6 and 1/400th sec.
- Indicate somewhere on the LED that the program line was now "2" (hi-speed) rather than "3" (depth).
__________
Now, if you could control the program line from the front e-dial in the way I expect (that is, if the camera would show you that it's using either hi-speed or depth or MTF) and if you could adjust the EVC using the rear e-dial, then I think you could perhaps adjust the exposure, at least in some cases, more quickly than you can if you're actually adjust the shutter speed or aperture with those same dials. Why? Well, say the camera initially suggests 1/200th sec and f/11 (after you hit the green button). Using the default option for the dials in P (hyperprogram) mode, if you wanted to increase the shutter speed to, say, 1/1000th sec and if you were using 1/3rd stop increments, you'd have to make quite a few turns of the dial to get to where you wanted to be. But if there were only three different program lines to be affected as you turn that dial, in most cases, you could get where you want to go with a SINGLE click of the e-dial. Because if you're at 2, you'd go back to 1 in one click, or forward to 3 in one click.
As I said, what am I missing (or misunderstanding)? Thanks for your patience.
Will