| Ode to the *ist Ds vs/ K5 and beyond... You know, every once in a while, it's a good thing toremember why we buy cameras, lenses, etc. It's to take pictures! Sure, some of us just like to buy shiny new things, but for the most part, it's about the captured image. Looking back through digital archives on my computer, Inoticed that the pictures taken with my original ist Ds were, well, pretty darn good. I still have the body, and it's 100% functional, and I still use it as awork shop camera to document builds, procedures, etc. I've been on quite the equipment ride since my first digital camera (starting with an Olympus E10, which had a great lens and made very goodpics, but good lord was its CPU SLOOOOOWWWWW). The Pentax ist Ds was my first DSLR, and it was so cool tome, I instantly bought into the hype as the new models came out. I just HAD to upgrade to get that next little perceived edge of improvement. So, then I gotthe K10D, the K20D, then the K7, and now my K5. I only kept the original ist Ds out of all those in between, and my current K5, and I'll tell you why I keptthe Ds. I still love that little camera, and the others, in my humble opinion,have yet to best it by very much. I'm going to put something out there, and you can feel freeto disagree. Each camera & sensor combo seems to have its own distinct personality, just as varied as old film types. Think about the ist Ds as VPN100, the K10 as Royal 400, the K20 as Ektar 100, the K7 as Fuji 200 and the K5as Agfa 50. Those may not be exactly spot on, I'm just winging it, but you should get my drift. To be honest, I got a little burned out on the upgrade bandwagon. The constant promise of better images and fixing one problem, justto introduce a new problem of another type in the new model. Biggest issue I'd say is has been focus and general QC (oil spots, buttons falling off, etc). I can work around funky menus or button replacement, carry extra batteries,adjust white balance, and even work within iso limitations and will suffer through post processing, but poor autofocus and QC issues has been sucking thejoy out of the upgrades. What's the point in Safox ver 10 zillion if I still have to manually adjust each lens in-camera? My old ist Ds seems to do fine with its antiquated Safox viii, it was just a tad slow is all. My ancient film cameras autofocus was spot on back in the 1990's. Why oh why can’t this seemingly simple problem be worked out in this modern age? Is it just me? I'm not really sure why I started this post. I don't post much, even though I've belonged to this forum, the old Pentax group listserver, and Dpreview for many years. I guess I just wondered how many still have their original Pentax 6mp DSLR stuck in a drawer somewhere, and really have given it a proper outing lately. I have, and what struck me is how good that little thing still is. Sure, the Ds has its faults. White balance being the worst offender, and jpg processing, but those never bothered me, I shoot raw, and WB is an easy fix. Don't rattle off statistics or features, I know on paper, in this feature driven world, the old Ds should be a door stop. Just take a good picture with it and look at it. Maybe, like me, you'll wonder how far have we really come? Do I really need the next latest greatest to take good pictures? Finally, after a couple years I've spent with the K5, I think Pentax came back to the Ds type of image, and surpassed it obviously. The K5 beats it in WB, speed, size, about every category really. I'm not sure I can explain how I feel, but it just seems like the K5 finally feels like the next real upgrade from the Ds, and the other models in-between were somehow less than worthy. I felt it (disappointment) immediately soon after each purchase.Not so with the K5... at least not until much later when the lens release button fell off and I had to send it in for repair, heh heh. I think the lesson I've learned is this: If you are a Pro,buy what you need to get the job done and helps make a profit. If you are just a hobbyist on a budget, I think it would do you well to realize right up front that no camera is perfect. If you have one that you like, enjoy the one you have until you wear it out or truly reach its limitations, or you'll waste your entire photographic life chasing some impossible dream, not to mention blow a whole lot of coin. At this point in my life, I’ve sat out on the new stuff awhile, keeping my K5 even with the temptation of the new model K5II and IIS,and am re-evaluating where I want to take my photographic journey next. I'll admit I've got the itch for full frame... If Pentax released one very soon, it might get my attention, if the QC reports are good, and independent tests say the autofocus is on par with the competition... I’d pull the trigger on one, but I just don’t see anything coming soon. If they don't release one, I might eventually jump ship, but even if I ever did, I can't imagine ever selling the Ds, it would feel like selling my dog. I'd keep the Ds and a few favorite lenses. A camera that can engender that level of loyalty is special,so in conclusion… Dear Pentax; Even if you botch everything else down the road, thanks for my little *ist Ds, ya done good. Eric
|