Originally posted by yucafrita Thank you, Paul! I know the thread about RT but it looks like nobody else has my issue with the colors between applications. I tried Silkypix but even there are color differences in the standard setting, com pared to DCU. Seems I yet have to play more with the programs...
It's not just you.
I never end up liking what I get from RawTherapee and the K10D, so last week I decided to take some images and compare what I get from Corel Aftershot Pro, Rawtherapee and DCU 5.6.2. I tried this over and over and probably spent at least a couple hours just working on basic development in all 3.
The result? There's nothing quite like Corel Aftershot Pro. With just some basic adjustments I get great, and I mean great colors and definition.
DCU is not too far behind, but only 95% there - if I don't change the White Balance. Once I have to change the WB, it is all lost. First because there should be a slider instead of a + and - buttons where you can't even see the changes in real time as you change the settings. And even just selecting the custom WB option already throws your colors off and I can never recover. It's the most frustrating thing I experienced, other than...
RawTherapee: I just could not match the output from either Corel ASP or the Pentax DCU. I tried everything, from the Auto Levels, to all the many options RT has, to the film simulations I installed (the Fuji color ones are the most useable, the rest, especially the Kodak presets, are just junk). I just couldn't get it to match.
I *think* the problem lies with how RT handles white balance and if I could figure out a way around that, I would get better results.
Here's an interesting review of the RAW engines between Aftershot Pro 3, Adobe Camera Raw and Capture One:
http://resourcemagonline.com/2016/05/we-compare-corels-aftershot-pro-3-raw-a...ure-one/66439/ I think ASP compares well with them. Don't miss the part at the bottom when the editor basically says the reviewer didn't do a proper job of comparing them in the context that they were created for, and for judging ASP on lack of sharpness when in fact it doesn't over-sharpen by default right off the bat like Lightroom does. If you look at the end results, you'll see ASP is actually a good option. I just wish it would support newer Pentax cameras like my K-S1. But for the K10D, it is fantastic. It's like it was made to get the best out of CCD sensors (and it probably was... it worked miracles even on the pictures from my old Sony DSC-P200 from 2005).
I'd say get the free trial for Aftershot Pro and give it a spin. If you like it, download all the free plugins:
http://www.aftershotpro.com/en/plugins/