Originally posted by TheEyesHaveIt Hi all,
I'd like to get myself a DSLR and the Pentax line is pretty appealing, but what are the reasons you all feel it is better than Canon or Nikon? For Pentax, I like the weather proofing (not sure if I'll ever need it but it provides peace of mind), the bodies tend to be a tad bit smaller, seems better priced. But Canon and Nikon are more "established" - easier to get deals on or get 2nd hand or sell later, good reputations for image quality, etc.
Would love to get your thoughts. Thank you in advance!
If you are serious about the question I will give you a serious answer because I was in that very boat.
It all depends on you. It depends on how good you want to be and if you really are going to stick with photography or not.
If you are starting out as a rank amateur knowing very little/next to nothing about photography you will find yourself doing a great deal of trial and error.
For example I started out being absolutely enamored by long lenses. A little over a year in and I am frothing to get a 31mm. I started out wanting all zoom lenses and now I shoot only primes (except one lens I am hanging onto which is my 70-200mm, my only long lens). I didn't think having a flash was a big deal at first, but now I got one for Christmas and I am kicking myself for not knowing better earlier.
With all that said, the camera you want will have all 100% manual controls. I don't want to say everything else is secondary, but for a learner having manual mode is vital to the learning experience (This is my opinion and others may differ in theirs)...
I bought all my stuff before they had MAP pricing but all the buying and trying stuff can get expensive. I would say don't buy new lenses at first. On the forum here you can find good used lenses from very honest people. If you have questions people here are super friendly to answer you directly and honestly. That said, don't scrimp on lenses. If you do, six months up the road you will wish you had chosen better and spent the money up front on highly recommended stuff.
Now all that said, with Pentax you will be able to get in and get started and employ all the same photography principals you would regardless of your brand of choice...and you will be able to do it at a much lower cost overall cost. And yes, once you know your way around things you will be able to go into other brands if you like. But at least at that time you (hopefully) will know more about what you really like and value.
Pentax lags in their AF system when compared to Canon and Nikon (at least in my experience with the latter), that said depending on what you are doing it might not matter one bit if a Nikon can AF .3 seconds faster than a Pentax and be silent in the process. You will pay double and even triple for similar quality in other brands...so is it worth it to pay $1500 more for a lens that has a silent AF that is .3 seconds faster if you are finding you like to shoot landscapes?
Other brands may have a broader array of lenses (again, my own opinion), but then again it all depends on what you want to do.
All that being said, you won't go wrong with Pentax...
Wouldn't it be nice if we could all start out with nothing but the best of the best of lenses on the best of the best full framed sensor cameras...If I was a Saudi Prince I would have all of the systems to be honest and the best of the best in way of lenses for each one...
But I would say this to us normal folks...photography isn't cheap and in general your gear will decline in value over time (except some lenses if they are well cared for)...especially if you actually use the stuff.
On your first car you aren't going to go out and worry about the paddle shifters on the steering column, the latest anti lock braking system, if you should get the V10 or the V12, or if it's worth it to get a 200mph top speed vs a 210mph top speed.
I won't say the other brands are bad, I will though say you will pay a lot more and get less, once you take into account the entire spectrum of stuff you will want/like to have and try.
After using Pentax for a year and a half... even if I won powerball tomorrow I would pick up some Nikon and Canon gear, but I would also have all that I wanted in the way of Pentax as well.