Originally posted by Damn Brit Not the magazines and videos but the content. ANIMAL CRUELTY. Got it?
Freedom of speech also includes that which many find abhorrent, unpleasant, disgusting, etc. Which is why the Supreme Court has ruled that also extends to most pornography, white supremist literature, etc. We are already far too dangerously close to evolving into the nanny state that England has become, without having every item in the Bill of Rights subject to the whines and complaints of every soccer mom in the country who wants something legal banned because they personally don't like it. This is a country of individual rights and freedoms, not lifestyle according to concensus.
I doubt Amazon makes any significant revenue off of those magazines, given the rather limited audience for such crap, and they clearly have more to lose over this than to gain, so I would expect it is a matter of principle. Once they bow to the pressure from the HSUS whackos - who are suing civilly because you know they'd be after them criminally if selling such magazines were a crime - then come the religious fundamentalists, the arch conservatives, the weak kneed, bed wetting liberals, and other assorted soccer mom groups.
Sue them and quit patronizing them until they drop all the cock/dog fighting magazines - but why stop there? They sell pornography - lots of people don't like pornography/erotica, so go after them for that as well. Oh wait... they also sell magazines about fighting. Horrors... bloodsports, many people think boxing and mixed martial arts should be banned - quick, sue them again. And (I know many won't believe this), they also sell gay and lesbian books and magazines/erotica... well, that's just plain disgusting - quick, let's boycott them again! And have you seen some of the religious stuff they offer? Why, some of that is just plain oppressive to anyone who doesn't hold the same beliefs - boycott 'em, I say! And on and on it goes.
In the end they (and any other bookstore) have their business - and what we have available as choices of reading material to purchase - run by a bunch of nanny-state pressure groups who want everyone to live according to THEIR mores. Once you've removed everything some intrusive bunch of busybodies don't like, what's left? Sure, it's legal to print your opinion/whatever and it's legal to buy it and read it - but our pressure groups have just made sure all that was shut down. Catch-22.
Frankly, while I hope all involved in dog fighting and cock fighting activities get their asses slung in jail, I also hope the HSUS gets their asses kicked in court with this lawsuit. The differences between them and PETA are increasingly vague every year. I don't need a bunch of jerks who make a living out of using the civil courts to try and do an end run around the Bill of Rights and other substantive law running my life. This particular issue doesn't affect me, but it's just a matter of time.
In fact, I think I'll have to show my support for Amazon by buying a Pentax 55-300 lens from them. Yeah... I need one of those.