For some perspective:
sm-02-09-22 My Favorite Lens
My experience tends to agree with Mike Johnson's.
The 43 Ltd is in a different league from the Takumars and just about any other 50mm lens.
The Takumar 55/1.8 is probably the most even in its performance, very excellent. I've had two, an Auto I still have, and a S-M-C.
The Takumar 50/1.4 has some magic, and have a bit of a change in character wide open. I have two - a Super and a SMC.
In general, especially with older lenses (we all age a bit differently, no?) I feel there's probably a greater sample variation than model ranking, at least within a family of lenses.
I'm equally happy to shoot with any of the above