Originally posted by clackers Well, now we certainly disagree, Dominic.
Perfectly all right by me, mate. Investigate the matter online and you will conclude as follows: people certainly disagree.
There are several factors:
(i) how shaky are your hands?
(ii) does your lens balance well?
(iii) do you perhaps have a camera with faulty SR?
(iv) are you a fanboy unwilling to admit the limitations to your system?
(v) have you actually bothered to carry out rigorous comparisons?
My point is that there is no clear-cut answer. I have carried out the mentioned experiment because I am considering buying into a second system without IBIS.
Worry not, life can be could good without SR as well; plenty of happy testimonies from Canikon users.