Originally posted by mcgregni Its an interesting problem you encountered, one of assumption and mis-information,whoever can be blamed. It just goes to show how complex the mix of camera modes and lens to camera contacts make the whole business of working with flash ...... explains why I ended up with 90 pages in my Guide!
I agree with the points made earlier about how much we can expect from a camera manual. I know Pentax could do more to explain the 'putting it into practice' aspects, but the manuals would end up being a great mishmash without much clear focus I fear. The Flash Guide was intended to supplement the manual by providing the practical context, and I did sort of cover this area in the following section, which I'll quote here .....
THE CAMERA : FLASH & EXPOSURE MODES (Page 28)
Now that we’ve considered the general principles of controlling flash and ambient exposures, I’m going to look at how the different camera flash and exposure modes specifically act to change the camera’s response, and practical ways to take control.
It is worth noting that on the Pentax DSLR’s there is no actual ‘Flash On / Off’ setting. Whether the flash will fire or not is dependent solely on raising or lowering the built-in flash, or fitting and switching on an accessory flashgun. There will always be one flash mode active at all times when a flash is ready to fire, depending on what is set on the flash mode display. Remember also that the Built-In flash and accessory flashgun will equally be affected by these Camera Flash and Exposure modes, but any additional mode settings on a flashgun will take priority over the camera set options.
Apart from the latest K-S2 & K3 cameras the Built-In flash units are P-TTL controlled only (the two latest models listed offer a 2-stage manual option also). Regardless of any camera exposure settings made, it will fire at a power determined by the P-TTL system. You are able to apply -2 to +1 stops of flash compensation to the flash exposure from the built-in unit, but this will be in relation to the camera determined flash exposure level. With an accessory flashgun you have additional flash compensation range for P-TTL working, and more extensive output control with its ‘Manual’ flash mode.
I've taken a note of this issue and will definitely try and address it more directly in the next update to the guide with some specific examples using the lens aperture ring as you have described.
Hi mcgregni, thanks for your interest & input, I have your PDF guide on my desktop, I've only skimmed it, and promised myself I'd get back and read it properly, a pitty I didn't do that before my unfortuate debacle, it might have saved me a lot of grief.
having considered all this for the last couple of days, and knowing what I now know about the popup flash I went back and re read the manual P236 237 & 238 " Using the inbuilt flash" and I can't see anything at all which would alert a novice or inexperienced flash user that the inbuilt flash will behave differently with an A type lens and a non A lens, and nothing at all to indicate when using an A lens with the camera set to M mode that the flash will still be operateing in an automatic mode. There may be clues to this in other parts of the manual but I would say that If I want to know about the operation of the inbuilt flash I go to the index look up the section to do with flash and go to the page marked "using the in built flash."
I'm an Electronics tech and have been involved in diagnosing & repair of complex electronic equipment & systems for the last 40 odd years, In that time I've used & read countless owners manuals, operation guides, service manuals, engineering updates etc. I have 3 filing cabinets + a number of boxes full of manuals & currently amost 20 gig of pdf manuals on file. I know a good Manual when I see one, My K30 manual is not a good one. Having said that, I thinks it's probably adequate, as the camera is well thought out and intuative to use, most of the manual is hardly needed at all, when I got my K30 I just whent straight out and started shootng for a few weeks before even picking up the manual. I think what
is not intuative is the operation of the fash system, be it inbuilt or external flash. I think most inexperienced users would agree. That's one area where the extra level of detail & explaination certainly is needed. I'm sure there may some other areas as well that could use some extra detail, but it doesnt have to be across the whole manual, just a few extra sentences where needed a few pages overall, it doesn't have to blow out the size manual at all just extra detail or background in the areas were people may struggle
Having read and used a lot of manuals ( & installation instructions for computer gear for that matter) one continual area of frustration is that by their very nature manuals are written by people that fully understand the equipment or system they are writing about, So the author can write a sentence or make a statement that to him is perfecly understandable, coveys exactly the infomation he's trying to get across and is totally unambiguous, but the reader who doesn't yet understand the the whole system & the implications of what he has just read, can be left scratchihg their head and not understanding. A few well chosen words at this point, in way of exra explanation can make all the difference
As an example, in this thread, several people tried to tell me exactly what was happening (and please don't misinterpret this as some sort of critisim or shifting of blame for me not getting it) by making the statement that my problem had been caused by preflash, something that I had dismissed because of a wrong asumption that I should be able to detect a preflash. So I was resistant to that suggestion because of my wrong asumption, and lack of understanding of the flash system. If the preflash suggestion had of been accompanied by the extra infomation that the preflash & flash happen so quickly that it's not really detectable with the naked eye, the bulb above my head would have lit up and the rusty old gears would have turned and within a couple of seconds I would have been on board with the Idea. tic tic tic..."That explains it all "
cheers
CC.
edit: by the way, for those that are interested - the time between preflash and flash is about 105 msec. (about 1/10 sec)
the pulse width of the preflash is about 25-30% that of a full power flash, not prepared to make any assumptions regarding power but possibly 25-30%.
My "dumb" strobes (no peflash setting, infact no controlls at all) have no detectable delay at all.(another wrong assumption)
PS. among some of my tech friends we have a saying " assumptions are the mother of all f--k ups" yet I still get caught on a regular basis.
Last edited by Cee Cee; 02-02-2016 at 10:00 AM.