Originally posted by FantasticMrFox I couldn't care less about field curvature and border sharpness as long as they are not
really bad. And I don't see the point in f/2.8 primes, might as well use a zoom then. I want something wide (24 mm), fast (at least f/1.8), quick (DC) and tough (WR) for documentary photography, where hardly anyone cares about curvature and border sharpness. It doesn't need to be DA Ltd. style tiny, but shouldn't be Sigma 35 'Art' big
Looks like we have pretty different priorities
Yeah, the things I want are nice rendering and that doesn't have soft border half of the time because in theory they are sharp but because of field curvature, well they are quite soft. DA15 and DA21 have the issue, the 21 to a lesser degree, but that's quite annoying.
I never have to complain of sharpness of the DA35ltd or the FA77, an FA50 is good too stopped down. Give me that overall and I'll be happy.
f/1.8 would be nice, but when I see the size of a FA31 f/1.8, I don't think you'll get a small 24mm. Ricoh will not make an APSC only lens when there already the 21 and there a lack from ANY WA prime. So either it will be a behemoh and fast, either I will need a moderate apperture like f/2.8...
As for why get a slow prime when there are zoom? Well just compare how you subjects will feel against a small f/2.8 prime or against a huge 24-70 zoom, and you'll get it.