Originally posted by Jasvox Yes, same length when not extended, which is how most people travel with it (wear around neck, in a bag, etc). My point is that it takes up no more room in your bag than the kit lens
True. My point is different - that the camera balances differently with smaller/lighter versus larger/heavier lenses when actually using it. You apparently prefer the way it feels with larger/heavier lenses, but I am very much the other way around - the DA40 is *by far* my favorite lens to shot with in this respect.
Also, how one might potentially *feel* different about shooting depending on how conspicuous one appears. And again, I suppose some might prefer the more "professional" look of a larger lens, I prefer blending in more. Although to be fair, when used in the 18-55 range, there really isn't much difference here - but that's another part of why I love the DA 40.
Anyhow, in practice I find that even when I have multiple lenses at my disposal, 90% of the shots I take on basic walk-arounds are covered by the 18-55 focal length. That is, I don't shoot telephoto nearly as much as I imagined I would at first, and it's usually pretty easy to anticipate based on where I'm going when I'll want to take a telephoto lens with me. So I feel I personally would be giving up too much in terms of the feel of actually taking pictures by adding all that weight and bulk to my camera when I didn't need it most of the time.
Others, of course, are more bothered by changing lenses every once in a while, and don't mind putting all their lens weight on the camera rather than carry the 18-55 on the camera with, say, a 50-200 in the bag for when it is needed. Note the overall weight of the bag is almost exactly the same either way, but I'm much less sensitive to the weight of my bag than the weight of the camera as I shoot.
Also, FWIW, the kit lens doens't feel like a toy at all to me, although to be honest, I don't actually use it all that much - most of my shooting is with one of my primes. If I feel like traveling simple and light and take only one lens, it's the DA40 if primarily indoors and the 18-55 if primarily outdoors.
Anyhow, I'm just pointing out that there *are* tradeoffs to be made that different people will make differently. Hopefully we've described the advantages and disadvantages of each and our own preferences well enough for the OP or others to be able to come to their own conclusions about what would work for them.