Originally posted by MadMathMind Look for yourself:
Lens advice: 31mm limited vs. hd 35mm f2.8 macro limited - PentaxForums.com Had it with three different copies of the 31. Even I'm not that unlucky. Effects like that are inherently part of wide-angle lenses especially as you head south of 35mm, but they can be corrected. The FA31 costing as much as it does without that correction on 60% of the frame makes it not worth its price. Every lens has to be understood to be used properly. No lens does everything well.
What I conclude from this are number of points.
It's inaccurate to call those large group shots "portraits". A portrait is different than a group shot, and this thread was about portrait lenses.
Almost any lens can be criticized because it doesn't do what it wasn't designed to do. I wouldn't criticize a macro lens because it doesn't do fisheye images. How is your criticism any different?
If you believe the 31 isn't good for portraits because it doesn't do large group shots well, I struggle to see the relevance.
If you read down your previous post, all the errors you present in your interpretation were pointed out, but you seem reluctant to benefit from the responses.
The "weakness" you point out is actually caused by correction to prevent distortion. You don't explain how adding more correction would create less distortion.
Don't go on lens reputation. Go on actual images for what you plan to do. Don't assume that because a lens is a top rated lens it will be good for what you want it for. It will be good for what it's designed for. Nothing more.
There are no "this lens is good for everything" lenses.
It is simply an error to call your large group shots "portraits". They're "group shots". I mention this because it might confuse new and inexperienced readers.
Personally I would be asking myself "How is it that so many good photographers have a different opinion than mine?' For myself it is in answering those types of questions that I eventually figure those things out. If you don't work through that, it's awfully hard to learn anything.