Originally posted by sflights Basically what I'm asking is if you had the choice for either, which one would you choose? I don't want a K20D because of it's noise issues and the 14.6 mp images.
I have a lens for my canon, but it has right side softness, and a nifty fifty, which I also have for pentax.
So again, which would you choose, and why?
Hi,
I had the oportunity to shoot the 30D and the K10 side by side for a few months (Pentax user since 1992).
K10 + DA12-24 + DA*50 135 + FA50f1.4 vs 30D + 50f1.4 + 70-200f4L IS:
K10 has better handling and a wider set of features & customization.
K10 also has a better screen (the 30D is one of the poorest I have seen).
IQ is a toss until ISO 400, with excellent sharpness at base ISO for the K10 but the 30D is no slouch. From ISO 800 on, the 30D is better (less noise and better DR).
AF is better in every way on the 30D, no matter in what kind of light. This ended up significantly impairing the results on my K10 with a much greater number of misfocused shots compared to the 30D.
In that aspect, the K20 represented a significant upgrade (I had it also for a few months) but in the end, Canon's AF is just better at the moment.
AE is also better on the 30D (more consistent) but if you use spot metering, you don't really care.
Then there is the 5fps the 30D offers: not critical for me but it definitely makes the camera "snappier".
Overall, I left the K10 with mixed feelings: very good interface and nice results when properly focused but too many approximations (AF, AE errors, especially in low light or when reflective surfaces are present, slanted VF...).
The K20 seemed more robust in almost every way and it would certainly be my main camera if I hadn't compared it to a 5D...
I don't think the K10 represents the best value from Pentax as of now and would definitely look rather at the K20 which would then be a better choice for landscape photography than the 30D. For other type of photography (especially when action is involved), I would probably still go Canon though).
Hopefully, I managed to confused the matter even more.... sorry for that!!
My dream camera would be K20 with 5D's sensor and AF, compatible with Canon's L zooms and Pentax primes... am I asking too much !!??
OK, maybe I am asking to much...
and so I had to prioritize IQ/AF over handling and transform a big collection of Pentax gear into a much smaller collection of Canon gear... but there isn't a day of shooting where I don't miss the K20 ergonomics.