Originally posted by cpopham That's a big overdramatic, don't you think. It's not really a vast conspiracy - with most products there is a target lifespan, but this is mostly due to controlling unit cost. You might be happy to pay more for a camera which will last longer, but how many others will?
It is no more over-dramatic than complaining about depreciation! I agree that it is not a conspiracy. Rather...it is a fact of life when it comes to consumer electronics and with good reason. Consider the early Wang word processors and IBM PCs. They were overbuilt (except, perhaps for the hard drives) and while still very serviceable, most were retired within their service life because of obsolescence.
Quote: With regards to repair, remember that most modern electronics are manufactured on partially, or fully automated production lines, with inventory delivered on a just in time basis.
To support servicing requires a stock of spare parts, sitting there, costing money while they wait to be useful. It also requires the time of a skilled human to repair the item. Given how aggressively manufacturing costs are minimised, is it really surprising that repair isn't economical for most of these items?
I could not agree more. Your explanation is one of the clearest I have read on this matter.
Quote: To give a parallel example, my day job is as a software developer (specialised business software). Generally, whenever any performance issues crop up, it is better value to simply buy faster hardware than it is to look at altering the software. Crazy? Yes, but the market wants the best return on investment, and that is how it is achieved.
I too, develop software for a vertical market...strangely enough they always expect me to make the hardware run better...go figure!
The point of my post was to remind people that their cameras are tools. Well-made tools, but tools, none-the-less. They also happen to be tools that have (for all practical purposes) parts that wear out and are non-replaceable. So rather than cry about depreciation, maybe we should always buy for the best value, get good use for our money, and not worry about how much the next guy is paying for the same item six months later.
Steve