Fashion pictures IMHO are not to be judged only by professionals.
But they are judged by everyone, because they are part of corporate marketing strategies, addresed to magazines/newspapers/internet/tv/mobile whatever.. and thus to customers.. to us!
If we find them impressive, touching us, appealing, or just telling the right "story" that will improve or maintain the status of a given brand name, or make us, the customers, identify with the advertised "product" ,whatever that may be, then it is a success story and potentially Art, in the eye of the beholder.
I would dare say that fashion photography covers almost all kind of photography styles, from old people portraits to landscapes with models and all kind of setups. On every site, on every street, on every magazine you can find fashion photographs.
After m$ in R&D, procurement, production/manufacturing blablabla It is in the photograper's/director's/artist's talent to make it sell..There exists alot in his hands than we see at first hand...
So fashion photography IMO is not just art but part of our everyday life that is judged by the most stringent judge, us, the potential customers. Of course this is just my opinion
Cheers!
Sam
__________________________________________________________
"The avalanche has already started...It is too late for the pebbles to vote"