Originally posted by elkarrde i don't agree with auto-zoom approach as a good approach for learning photography.
i think that's the worst way - it'll make your son lazy and technology-dependant.
*istDL will happily meter the light with any lens you attach to it, it will set the shutter according to selected lens aperture, it's really no more complicated than with fully automated lens, but it does require some thinking. i would say, that's good thing.
after all, 30 years ago kids were shooting with fully manual cameras without problems, so why should it be a problem today?
I agree with you to a point. Having the automatic option allows his son to experience it all and not walk away frustrated if he isn't one that will learn manual exposure real fast. Learning composition is just as important as learning exposure, so when the aperture and ISO get confusing, he can still flip to auto and learn composition.
Also, I think kids are different today...they are always different with passing generations. Think I'm wrong? How many boys 40 years ago were into typing?
That was "girls" stuff back then. Today, you can't get them away from a computer. Different application and technology...technology that allows them to use an old skill (typing) in a whole new arena of communication. Now they are motived to learn because they see a benefit to learning. If they see the same benefit with their camera (i.e. can see the end result with automated settings), they will be more apt to want to learn the how and why...more of an "instant gratification" turned into a learning experience approach.
While at their heart all generations of kids are really the same, every generation grows up in a different technological world which in turn shapes their experiences. Today's generation is one of "instant gratification"...not every kid, but as a whole this is true. This is because the world is so "automated" that they have a hard time seeing why it's important to learn the "old way". Having the automatic as well as the manual abilities maybe easier for him to relate to and makes it easier for him to learn the right way rather than just pushing him in the deep end of the pool.
Now, that being said...if he is one of those that loves a challenge and can motivate himself, by all means go manual!