Originally posted by Eric Seavey I still like the Noise Ninja performance best though the black in Topaz Denoise look much darker.
I will admit, it took a while to understand and get TDN to work properly coming from wavelet based noise reduction software like NNinja and Noiseware Pro. However... I can assure you that TDN is far and away better at noise reduction than both those programs.
Looking at your samples I'd say you didn't optimize your the red and blue channels properly. Additionally, there is highlight level noise where none should be had, so you might want to try and adjust that slider as well.
One quick and dirty way to get a better feel for what's going on with TDN is to make use of the channel viewing options. This way you can better identify the type
of noise you are working with and how to best address it.
PS. I'm posting this entirely on assumption. Without seeing the original files, it's really not possible to know exactly how each system responds to the images.