Originally posted by arbib That is the kind that has to stay on the camera, and be taken off separately. I had one, and it was a real pain to use the tool to get it off my Film body. Thanks for INF info too.
That was the first one I found in my eBay search. It happened to be a third party adapter.
When I got my third party adapter, it took a little while to get used to using the tool. After I got the hang of it, though, I could remove the adapter with almost anything that was handy, including a ballpoint pen tip.
However, as I said in the post just previous to the one you responded to, the spring clip on my adapter fell off. Many people remove them anyway. Once it was off, the adapter could be removed with the lens. Since I only have one M42 lens that I ever use on my K10D, I leave the adapter on that lens, effectively turning it into a K-mount lens. When I want to remove it, I simply rotate the lens about 1/8 turn counterclockwise and it pops off in my hand, with the adapter still firmly attached to the lens.
So, no, it does not have to stay attached to the camera.
Many people claim that the genuine Pentax adapter is much easier to remove. I have never used one, so I can not comment on that. I have never had any trouble with my third party adapter.
Any adapter that will allow infinity focus is going to be designed to stay on the camera. They all have a sheet-metal spring clip to lock the adapter in place, since M42 lenses lack the hole for the lens lock pin. Some adapters are machined to closer tolerances than others, but all that allow infinity are of the same basic design.