Originally posted by OutOfFocus Exactly. (I did say that above the graph, but perhaps it isn't too clear.)
The graphs also show that the camera is turning off for the non-LSD batteries much, much earlier than it is for the LSD batteries, which it can totally drain. The question is why is that? The voltage curves for the non-LSD batteries intersect somewhere near a bit over 1.2 volts at a current draw a bit less than 1 amp. Is that significant? It seems a weird point for either alkalines or NiMH batteries, but it's not unreasonable for Lithiums. Wild speculation: could the camera be mis-guessing the battery type as Lithium?
Could you validate your guess by setting the battery type to NiMH?
Sorry for my misunderstanding - just take what I said as me mumbling to myself to get my own thoughts clear
As for an explanation - only of sorts -
If we assume the Kx (and other Pentax dSLRs using AA size batteries) use voltage threshold.
Then the theoretical explanation is that both the eneloop and Imedion appear to maintain their voltage under the Kx load better than any of the other non-LSD batteries - to the point where the non-LSDs may only be partially discharged before they can no longer maintain the voltage level required to keep the Kx working. Whereas both the eneloop and Imedion can do so.
Here's an animated graph showing this comparing eneloop with the typical high capacity non-LSD NiMH -
the
red-line at 1.15V - is the tested cutoff voltage for the K200D -
(NOTE: to be fair - the horizontal scale in the second animated comparison are not the same for the higher capacity NiMH, their ranges are wider (better) )
NiMH rechargeable batteries native nominal voltage is 1.2V - so this is already at a disadvantage when it comes to Pentax dSLRs - and as they are used, the operating voltage under load sags - depending on the current demand - and this can be as high as ~1.5Amps. (for more details please see this thread -
K200D Battery Meter Problem specifically Post #
23 )
Also as NiMH batteries age - they start to develop higher internal resistance - which limits the amount of current they can deliver - so the operating voltage under load sags even more.......
eneloops manage to maintain a higher operating voltage under load than any other NiMH rechargeables - this is trivial for almost any other application -
BUT for the Pentax dSLR this is a
HUGE advantage - please see post #
28 (link) in the same referenced thread above. (also
eneloop vs. Kodak Pre-Charged Voltage Maintenance summary post #
57 , also please see #
61 )
taken from my post #
4 in thread:
Problem with Ni-MH rechargable batteries in K200D/K-M
EDIT to ADD -
I just did a discharge to see the remaining capacity of my eneloops depleted in my new Kx until shutdown -
it was in the 20-33mAh range (Maha C9000) so they were pretty much completely (safely) depleted.
So this confirms the Kx is capable of utilizing almost the full capacity of eneloops.
Perhaps my lower shot count is merely me playing with a new toy and wasting battery capacity?