Originally posted by junyo Thanks for that link - I had not thought of that.
It is correct if we are dealing with very shallow depth of field.
However for years with MF lenses there was only central focusing on SLRs and rangefinders (eg: Leicas) - where would photographers focus if they were doing a half or 3/4 length portrait? I would almost guarantee it would not be the center of the frame somewhere on the body/clothing - most of us did focus on face/eye and recompose.
Now I'd be the first to agree that just because the way it's been done does not necessarily make it the best, or even the right way.
However there is just too much empirical evidence in the overwhelming number of great photographs out there - before AF -
that clearly show center focus recompose to be very workable -
including I'll bet the person that you quoted in your own sig line - Robert Capa -
he would have to focus somewhere, and I'll wager it was not always at the center of the frame -
surely Mr Capa was not using "crappy practice"...... ?
However the article you linked to is correct -
and I have already taken note. Thank you.