Originally posted by Alfisti I already answered that question, you need to work when the dynamic range exceeds that of the sensor and when colours clash. Try exposing an image with a lot of red, if you expose 'correctly' you will blow the red channel to smitherines or you live with a very dull and flat file for the rest of the image, red being far more demanding than most colours. Or, you expose for the highlights and pull the reds down in post with the extra headroom RAW gives you, THEN you convert to 8 bit.
Not to mention, do you think the same level of sharpening and saturation is suitable for a portrait as it is for an image of a bright flower with lots of detail?
You're suggesting all images are the same which is flat out wrong.
Actually, no I'm not saying all images are the same.
The point is that about 98% (number not for dispute, this is a WAG) of all photos taken do not benefit significantly from RAW,
Photos that do, as you have pointed out can be done in RAW, that's why my default is JPEG with RAW+ at the push of a button.
The point I am trying to make in all of this is that if you have situational awareness (and you should if you are a pro or semi pro) you know when you will need RAW and when JPEG is sufficient, as well as what settings you need.
A lot of the arguments surrounding RAW, like some of the ones I responded to are flat out wrong. You can make many of the same adjustments in either JPEG or RAW, there is nothing that says you cant, and for fine adjustments in the mid range of images you don't need the extra data.
If you are always working at the edges of the exposure range, sure RAW can give a little more, but how often are you always working in that range?
however, at the end of the day it is the results that matter and if anyone is satisfied with their shots or prints, regardless of how they got there, then it is OK.
My only point is to try to get as close as possible when I take the shot, not later. That's all. In a response to a similar thread once, I was accuesed of "Pre- Post Processing" because I made situational adjustments of my JPEG settings as I shot.