Originally posted by falconeye I am not sure, but FWIW ...
I believe that the only common HDTV modes are
- 720p@50/60Hz
- 1080i@50/60Hz
- 1080p@50/60Hz
- 1080p@24Hz (more recently)
So, a 1080p@25/30Hz stream may simply not play if connected to a HDTV. At least, I can only select from the above list to connect my media center to HDTV.
I cannot speak for Europe but in the US, the only television/HDDVD/Bluray modes are 720p (progressive) which shows 60fps, 1080i (interlace) which shows 30fps and 1080p which shows 60fps. Now in cinema, I get to understand that there exists a 1080p 24fps mode to compliment cinema film frame rate but I will skip that for now.
In 720p, 1080i and 1080p, the camera films at 60 shots per second (60Hz refresh rate) but in progressive modes, (720p/1080p), each shot is a complete frame scanned one line at a time from top to bottom. In interlace mode, (1080i), each shot alternates even lines from top to bottom then odd lines from top to bottom so two shots are required to produce a full resolution image so each full resolution image occurs once every 1/30th of a second or 30fps. Nevertheless, the refresh rate is 60Hz.
So apparently, if the camera is shooting 1080 resolution at 30/24fps but recording at 1080i 30/24Hz then the camera is taking full frames every shot but throwing away half the data to form an interlaced frame in which case you can only be getting 15/12fps 1080i @30/24Hz. This is not true HD.
The only other thing I can think is that the camera is shooting at 30/24Hz, dividing each frame into two interlaced frames thus doubling the amount of half images for 60/48Hz, and combining them, interlaced, at 60/48Hz to produce a 1080i 30/24fps movie. The problem with this is that in true interlace mode, each half frame is to be a picture advanced in time by 1/60th (or 1/48th) of a second.
In this case, the first and second half frames are the same point in time and the third and fourth half frames are 1/30th or 1/24th of a second ahead in time. This will not make smooth video but more like stop-motion filming at thirty images per each second of motion but only moving the models between every second image instead of between each image.
Tim Burton is rolling in his grave!