Edit:
Page 4 and 6 have some sample shots with the D600. Page 4 includes a series shot with both the K5 and D600.
Page 7 has some more "scientific" comparison shots.
Page 12 compares the FA 77mm limited on the D600 and K5 using the Fotdiox lens adapter
Page 12 has a few comparison shots of the bodies of the K5 and D600
Page 12 also has a collection of images taken with the D600
Page 13 has more photos, and a revelation.
update: D600 has been sold as of 6.7.13, I will post final findings soon. I am now awaiting the arrival of the D800
I love my Pentax, and I love my K5. I had a plan, yesterday I was going to complete my FA limited collection with the 43mm and the 31mm lenses. Then I was looking through my photos and found spots on all photos taken from my #1 K5 body. I did some tests, found out its on the sensor, and sent it in for repair. Warranties up now... funny thing is I just got it back from Pentax last month after it fell and they replaced the LCD screen. It did not have spots before that drop, or after when I was shooting with the cracked screen. The spots just showed up when it came back from Pentax repair depot. I have a second K5 and have been putting it to good use.
So why the change of plans? Well... it changed three times. first off, I decided I would buy a new guitar instead. I haven't expanded my guitar collection in a long time, and the guitar I've been searching for for a long time showed up at a local store. A late 1970's Gibson RD. They make three models, and this was the mid range model. Not exactly what I wanted... (I wanted the top end model of course), but it's a unique guitar and there were not very many made, so I went to check it out. Guitar was over priced, needed new frets, and the electronics could use a good clean. Big play ability issues, probably worth $500 to fix it. Price is already $400 over the ebay and other internet sellers for a top end model, let alone a mid range one. I told them I'd buy it at asking price if they fixed all the issues. They said they will contact the owner monday and get back to me.
So on the way home, I saw a digital banner of a D600. I decided to go in and check if my K5 was back from repair anyways, so I decided to check out the D600. Checked my bank account...checked the pricing, and pulled the trigger. I'm a lil choked that they gave me a free copy of Lightroom 4. I don't need Lightroom 4, I got that already. But no substitutions. I may take it back and goto a competitor that is offering 2 free 32gb class 10 cards instead. Or see if I can talk them into giving me the wireless adapter. I also picked up the 85 1.8G lens, coming out cheaper than the standard kit lens which I wouldn't like anyways due to the slowness and variable aperture.
I had a family portrait session today, and almost exclusively used the D600. After spending an hour setting up the camera I find that it's very easy to transition from Pentax. Some things bug the crap out of me, like the zoom buttons instead of zoom wheel for example, or the fact I can't figure out how to get the AF beep to come on (might be something wrong as the manual states I have it setup right). I also can't figure out one push bracketing...
I'm confused on how I feel about the build quality. Don't get me wrong, it feels like a quality product. But it's not build like the K5. The lens feels incredibly cheap (but it was only $500), and I think thats because they spent all the money on the glass, because it's really sharp and has great color rendition and contrast. The body doors and movable parts don't have the satisfying feel or click of durable long lasting materials like the K5. The shutter is a lil plasticky slappy sounding, and all in all it's not much heavier than the K5 with DA*16-50 f2.8 loaded up. The big thing I found funny was, that even thought he D600 is a larger camera, its harder to hold. During the studio shots I found my pinky kept falling off the grip, something that just doesn't happen with the K5. and I do have smaller hands. Wearing gloves (winter) I found once again the K5 was easier to control... Both are easy to use, even with the gloves I wear, but the K5 was just easier to hold and shoot with.
However, once I had it setup for basic manual shooting just like my K5, I felt at home. It really does feel good to shoot with, and very satisfying. It has a habit of over exposing I feel, but only by half a stop or so. I only use center weighted metering and focusing, and I found it handled very well for my needs. I love this viewfinder, it's very bright and lets you see everything thats going on. Very easy to confirm focus and compose with. No complaints there at all. and I really really love the menu system. It's so easy to get around and while not as customization a camera as Pentax, it does look good. No hit against Pentax here, the menu systems on Pentax's are fantastic as well. There is no better or worse here, jsut different. The screen though... thats amazing.
This is one of the photos from the shoot. Not a lot of touch ups needed. But I did find I don't have as much room to pull shadows or highlights like I do on the K5... which could be an issue because I am so used to the wide dynamic range of the K5 that allows me to pull details from the shadows without screwing things up. But I didn't have to do any color corrections, and I love how sharp and vibrant everything is. Fantastic combo this D600 and 85G lens.
So lets do the pro's and cons: (updated June 02, 2013)
D600 pros'
full frame finder
wonderful screen
lots of customizable buttons
similar ergonomics to Pentax
quite light for the size
big buffer
beautiful accurate colors when using LR4 camera profiles
accurate auto white balance
dual memory card slots
fast and accurate auto focus
larger resolution - larger print size
low light iso performance
drive modes on its own dial
almost every image has the "3D" effect seen with the FA Limited lens series
Battery life is as good as the K5
adapter for wireless tethering to iphone/ipad/andorid device is cool
flash system is just fantastic
ability to zoom in while using live view is fantastic for manual focus
auto focus is quick and accurate.
auto focus system tracks well
diopter adjustment has a good range
"My menu" function is fantastic.
dynamic range is better in the highlights than expected
on the fly metering for lenses without an auto aperture mode
manual focus indicators
D600 cons
grip is too small or odly shaped compared to K5
dyanmic range is not as wide (or so it seems)
plasticy feeling and sounding
some menu options are complicated
no folder naming by date
some controls just don't make sense
not as much customization options as Pentax
dedicated ISO button is in a crappy spot, and cannot be assigned to a more accessible function button
manual focus through view finder is surprisingly difficult.
G series lenses feel very very cheap compared to comparative lenses by Pentax
some custom button settings are redundant due to dedicated buttons.
some features that should be customized to these buttons are not available
auto focus system hunts in low light. maybe even more so than my K5
focus points are too spread out (and there could be more of them)
no aperture control in movie mode is really irritating
"weather sealing" and build quality do not give me confidence for shooting in Alberta winters/extreme cold, or heavy rain
shutter is very loud compared to K5, even in "quiet mode"
have to menu dive for certain common features (like interval shooting mode. AF release/focus priority)
need to setup "my menu" to a custom function button to access it quickly without menu diving for your custom menu
dynamic range in the shadows isn't as "natural" as it is on the K5. have to pull more from the shadows in D600 exposures
added depth of field can be a disadvantage in certain situations
no stability control unless used with certain lenses.
So far the honey moon is going about as expected. Part of me feels that running two systems is not going to work out in the long run and one of them will be left behind. I'm already so deep with Pentax it's hard to see me leaving it behind. The Pro's are not outweighing my Pentax system enough for me to do a full swap...yet. I still have yet to decide if the larger print abilities and IQ are enough to warrant keeping it. The FA limiteds and DA* lenses offer pretty amazing photo quality already, and they are considerably smaller/lighter. I still got a few days before I run out of a returns window. If the guitar shop calls me back and accepts my offer, I think the D600 will be returned and I'll go with that plan. vintage instruments are harder to find again than a brand new digital camera...and it will give me longer years of service.
edit: guitar shop did call back. I got the camera and the guitar because I like to be broke like that.
edit: 6 months later
The honey moon is far from over, we are now in month 6. The first six months were full of "this is awesome", "why did I ever buy this", "why can't I find a buyer to take this off my hands". "maybe better glass would help get the most out of this camera". "I'm really not that good of a photographer if I can't get a keeper from this so called amazing camera", "wow thats sharp". "wow thats a big image", "why are all the colors so bland", "I love this autofocus".
Well now, I can honestly say I love this camera and I will be sticking with the Nikon system for a while, won't need to do much more expansion. For sure a fast "normal zoom" with image stabilization, another flash gun or two. The rest is on the "want list"
Some tips on how to get to D600 bliss faster:
1) When shooting in RAW, and using Lightroom 4 to develop your photos, make sure the first thing you do is select a "camera profile" at the bottom of the develop module. Set this to whatever you had the camera set at when you captured the image. Since I love vivid high contrast images...I always throw this on the vivid setting
2) Understand very quickly that while shooting in low light at 1.8 seems like a good idea as it worked all the time on your Pentax... its not a good idea here. The depth of field is way too thin for you to get the same amount of sharpness. Sure, having that option to get what seems like an ultra slim slice of focus...really you should be looking at f2.8 for most of your shots where you shot 1.4 on your Pentax system. 2.8, go for f4. I find I sit in the F4-F8 a lot more than I ever did on my Pentax kit now.
3) Right tool for the right job. If I'm going out to do some street photography, maybe a some concerts, telephoto, or places with low light... I'm taking the K5, especially if I need a walk around camera for the day. If it's bright, sunny, or I'm doing work with strobes, portraiture, long exposure landscapes...D600. This is just to use the best of each system to its advantages
4) because of the thinner depth of field, if your shooting center spot focus all the time and do the focus and compose trick, and your shooting f2.8 or faster...chances are your image is going to be out of focus. Use the focus points and move them around.
Last edited by Wired; 06-07-2013 at 01:36 PM.