Originally posted by LesDMess just to be sure, have you shot any slide film and if so which ones?.
I have, albeit not much. Some of the Agfa stuff and a roll of Provia 100F. I have some friends (and their parents, haha
) that have shot more slides, don't know what film exactly that I had a look at. Those were all prints though, not projected or viewed on a light table. What struck me was that either there was a blue, purple or green cast to them, or the look was very 'bland', for lack of a better word. But both Portra and Ektar are films with a signature look that is easily recognised, that probably plays a role too.
Originally posted by chickentender You "despise" the look of Velvia? DESPISE? Really? Wow. I wonder how you feel about people that kick children and puppies... (I'm kidding)
Truly though, if you don't care for Velvia, but you enjoy Portra, I would have a go with Velvia 100F - most people who love RVP100 or RVP50 (the "true" Velvias) do not care for 100F nearly as much because its color rendering is much more neutral. I personally love the stuff for everyday shooting just for that reason... It still has Velvia punch to my eye but without being as heavy-handed as the other emulsions can get.
Hahahaha you crack me up good
It's true that I don't like superdupersaturated colors in general. Yes, I know Ektar ain't natural looking either, but it doesn't have the purplish blue cast that a lot of Velvia shots have. I'll give the 100F a try, it does look a lot more pleasing for what I generally want from a film
Originally posted by gofour3 Yep you can only truly judge a slide by looking at it on a light table or projected. My scans of slides are NEVER as good as the original, some are close but others way off. The same holds true for prints of slides. It used to be better years ago when the labs used internegatives and it was all analog. Digital has ruined the impact of shooting slides more than negatives, as with a negative you don't have anything to compare the scan/print to.
I didn't really know that scanning slides made them so much worse. I always thought they'd be easier since you have true colors already, instead of having to muck about for hours trying to get an inverted negative to look good.