Quote: I couldn't agree with you more Seamus. However..."...durable than your probably roughly handled CD's" can easily be construed as being a personal attack.
that was meant as a general statement for how a lot of people tend to handle their Cd's, not a direct attack at you.
Quote: As a trained audio engineer I can tell you that you are confusing several different factors and that nostalgia for vinyl is simply that
I never claimed to have nostalgia for vinyl, maybe I wasn't clear enough. I was referring to modern studio techniques for engineering music
and remastering older music.
Quote: Mastering is an incredible art. Those that brickwall limit every track produce horrible music, but that is irrespective of whether the delivery medium is analogue or digital.
that pretty much sums up what I was getting at. and I never claimed that vinyl was better than CD, or digital in general for that matter, I was only referring to the crap quality of the everyday mp3 file most people listen to nowadays and don't seem to realize how bad it is. I don't have nostalgia for vinyl I grew up with it because my father had a very large collection *which now belongs to me) and I just continued to listen to and add to my collection as I grew up. vinyl records for me are what Ive always used not CD's or audio cassetes. this all goes back to what I was saying about 'superiority' not always being the reason a person uses one thing over another.
Quote: There's distortion everywhere. Yes, it's a nice distortion that people have learned to love. But it's still not part of the music.
something thats easily solved with a laser turntable and a quality record. if you can afford the turntable that is.