Originally posted by Spodeworld Hi. Just picked up a Spotmatic. Would like to do some B&W and was wondering which of the above you guys prefer and why. Thanks
I would agree with every previous post. Here are a couple more ideas to consider:
Tri-X is much more consistent with different developers. TMax is compatible with traditional developers, but to really produces enhanced shadow detail, you need to use Kodak TMax developer:
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/29117-REG/Kodak_8446163_T_Max_RS_Developer.html
If you have any experience with Ilford films, the difference between Tri-X and TMax is like the difference between HP5+ and Delta 400.
A great tool to 'preview' the tonal response, contrast, dynamic range, and grain will look like can be done on Nik Collection's free Silver Efex Pro 2. If you take a jpeg and open it in this free app, on the right side there is a "Film Types" menu that include both Tri-X and TMax and it will show you a simulation of how the two films would produce different gray scale results. Note: There are a ton of developer manipulation that can alter your actual results.
Google Nik Collection