Its an interesting thread - as someone who learnt with film (because thats all there was) and then moved too digital during my professional career I can see both sides. Digitals do give you the chance to mess about more readily and in fact my brother in law (who is also a professional photographer) runs most of his non-pro work off an iPhone where he adds in the special effects and he turns out some pretty stunning images. It would be easy to think that all you needed was the same iPhone and you too would take great images like his. You'd be very wrong because the trick is he has a fantastic eye for composition and finds gallery quality pictures where most of us, and I include me in that, would never find 'the shot'.
Thats the problem with a pro - they make it look easy
Is digital better - I can only relate personal experience which would be this..................
Back in the day when I was young and bright eyed and didn't need to worry about diopter adjustments with a viewfinder I bought myself an OM-1 when they were cool and then I bought an OM-2 and some lenses and before long I had a kit bag stuffed full of Olympus lenses, motor drives and probably almost every filter ever made - sepia, polarisers, soft focus, fog, red and yellow and blue and green, starbursts in 4, 6, 8 point and on and on. Weirdly the more gear I bought the worse the pictures became. When I look back at stuff I was shooting then the pics were bland but the effects were awesome (Hoya and Cokin should have hired me). The output was a bit like a Hollywood spectacular - the CGI is amazing but the storyline sucks.
Lucky for me an old pro lived round the corner and he was running some evening classes. Being young and already knowing far more than any person living (or so I thought) I felt it would be a waste of time but in the end I grudgingly parted with my money and signed myself up for a class. The learned old wise man looked over my stuff and, puffed on his pipe and then handed me a Mk1 Box Brownie and said 'here - take this and put a roll of black and white in it and don't come back until you have exposed the whole role and work at getting 10 solid pictures that show you actually thought about stuff. With a basic wooden Brownie photography becomes a real challenge. Fixed 30/60th shutter speed, steady hands essential and of course you have a fixed lens and its totally down to getting solid composition and a shot thats within the limits of what the box can actually take (motor racing and airshows are most definitely out
).
I can honestly say I learnt more from that exercise than any other lesson. The problem you see was believing the marketing and PR and believing the tech could produce the picture for me - we all do it and anyone who says they don't is fooling themselves. We are hard coded to want to believe its going to be better but the PR had spoofed me and I had gotten sloppy - don't worry about the camera being level it can be post processed out, don't worry about framing because you can always crop at the developing stage. Don't worry about depth of field because that can be masked and faked in the darkroom. Doing even bother choosing the right film because it can all be handled in the darkroom afterwards. Don't worry about great composition the filters will make the back of a bus look amazing !!! The consequences were much wasted film, much angst and an awful lot of bland pics and wasted chemicals. I shot so much back then I could probably lay a claim to being part of the planets pollution problems.
Digital carries with it the same curse - yes you can experiment faster and get quicker results but I have found with digitals I very quickly drop back into bad habits and rely on the post processing to sort out the flaws rather than focusing (pardon the pun) on getting it right from the start. With a modern digital I can put 3000 pics on the memory so why not just keep shooting but the problem is I never really learn much so when by chance the good shot emerges its hard to know exactly what I did so its tough to repeat. On the upside the pollution to the planet is maybe less
Is digital better than film or vice versa - its horses for courses and at the end of the day if its your hobby you do what makes you happy and thats a personal choice - far be it from me to issue diktats on what people should do with their time and money. For me I found turning pro turned my hobby into a profitable business but at the cost of killing the hobby and any enjoyment I got from photography became strictly financial and I ended up scarcely ever taking pics when someone wasn't paying.
I packed it up about 10 years ago and only recently the bug has bitten again to get shooting. I still own a small digital pocket cam and its fun to run some stuff on but I dread spending the time in front of the PC editing stuff down which is why I probably have about 10 bazillion pics that have never even been looked at and thats why I just bought into film again. It will moderate my shooting and. I hope, reteach me the lessons of that old Black Magic Brownie. For me as well its a bit about a post mid life crises and going back to my roots but theres also a charm in older cameras that modern digitals seem to lack - I have my dads Agfa Silitte sat next to me and I know it will take pics todays as good as it ever did - it was manufactured in 1958 when dad was a senior manager at Agfa. It outlived him and will probably outlive me - can you honestly say any digital will last a fraction of that time. Cameras back then were crafted - today they are all coming off some robot droid production line and for me at least they seem soulless. You can't pitch soul to people - they either feel it or they don't. Its a charm in the way that some people like too drive old cars or play vinyl LPs.
Heres something to think about though - someone smarter than me once said 'The greatest art is produced when the resistance of the medium is at its strongest' - in other words if its too easy you don't get much art because its the limitations that force the creativity out of you.
And now I am off to puff on my pipe and give some young person a box brownie in my turn