Originally posted by k100d i'm gonna be critical at what you've written here. what is so 'simple' about those pictures. and it's not like film cameras cannot have auto exposure, i can just fire away with my pentax film gear as well. and conversely, just because you have a digital camera doesn't mean you can get a well exposed well framed shot either.
it's like cheating then maybe we should all go back to typewriters too because word processors are cheating too.
I can see how you could interpret Peter's thoughts in this way. Digital provides a quicker means of feedback to enhance and speed up learning -
IF the person behind the camera can recognise flaws, exposure problems and interpret the histogram correctly for the desired effect.
Being forced to learn from first principles makes someone seriously think hard before releasing the shutter, something that is done less with digital. I did this myself. Even after I got my first dSLR, as I'd not mastered the basics of photography, I wanted to delve deeper and learn how to create the shot myself.
So I read a lot and bought myself a simple, fully manual film SLR coupled with some ordinary zooms and a 50mm prime. Which each roll of film I tried new ways of creating new styles of photos, and learnt "the hard way". Now I look back at that stage and think I could probably have done just as well with the K100D, only quicker, but the film SLR compelled me not to release the trigger on any shot without being sure of the settings first. The common factor in people growing in photography is the heart and a right attitude to learning, not necessarily the method employed.
Quote: if you use digital and you mess up one shot, then you work harder at the next shot. so the feedback loop is much shorter. by the time most people get their roll of film back, they've probably forgotten what they did that messed up that picture anyways.
i love film, but there's no need to be patronizing. everybody uses the equipment they choose for different reasons. generic common remarks like "manual exposure makes me smarter", "film makes me a better shooter", "primes make me work better", that's all mental.
The fundamentals of photography still apply on digital, and if being taught properly, learning will be just as good, just faster. A misguided photographer will find digital feedback fun but not a teaching or guiding tool for improving results.
Originally posted by Dangermouse I see it as the difference between a new Nissan GTR and a classic Lotus.
I knew a car analogy had to come in at some stage!