Originally posted by sideshow Hi,
I'm new to the forum (K-x is about 30 mins old to me) and just browsed this thread, but I didn't see anything about anyone using a voltmeter or multimeter to measure the AA battery voltage.
I think measuring individual voltages will be more telling rather than just going by advertised mAh battery life since I see some of the batteries from the first post listed in the "working" and "not working" categories.
First off, my K-x works really well with good quality NiMH. I've taken 2600 shots in one test with 2100 mAh batteries, and I've taken over 2 hours of video in another test of 2700 mAh batteries and I still have an orange indicator! I'm totally satisfied with my K-x battery performance (and every other category of performance as well), provided I use really good NiMH.
To get a good indication of NiMH performance, you need to measure the voltage under load not just the open-circuit (unloaded) voltage. The problem with high current devices such as digital cameras is that the internal resistance of the battery becomes very significant, which is why alkalines perform so poorly. As NiMH age they tend to develop (relatively) high internal resistance, and some brands (i.e. the battery's internal materials and construction) have higher resistance than others. Mistreatment (excessive over-charging and dis-charging) can also increase internal resistance, quite quickly.
A theory I have about the K-x's battery problems is that it incorrectly classifies some batteries as not NiMH, even if you tell it they are (i.e. it treats the battery type field as a hint, not the truth), based (in part) on the battery's internal resistance.
So, to get a better idea of your batteries' true state, measure both their open circuit voltages (as you have) and their voltages under a couple of different (significant) loads. If you look above (post 194) you'll see a graph I made using four different loads: open circuit, 3.33 ohms, 0.77 ohms, and 0.434 ohms. The voltage versus current plots are pretty much straight lines, so it wouldn't matter what resistances you used. I would suggest getting two 1 ohm 10 watt resistors, and then you can measure voltages under 2 ohms (resistors in series), 1 ohm (one resistor), and 0.5 ohms (resistors in parallel).
The graph I made above was at the point at which the batteries could no longer power the camera. I am in the middle of constructing another graph for batteries fresh off the charger. So far it shows that the low resistance batteries can power the camera for a very long time and are completely drained, while the high resistance batteries can only power it a short time and still have a lot of charge remaining.
If you'd like to post/pm your voltage measurements under load, I could add them to the graphs I'm building.
Last edited by OutOfFocus; 12-02-2009 at 12:15 PM.
Reason: fix typo