Originally posted by PBandJ I just viewed that video, and NIK looks awesome! But I wonder, being a newbie and all, doesn't it render Lightroom 4 [which I just bought :-(] redundant? I would like to know how or which Lightroom adjustments you use before using Nik?
Thanks
Originally posted by vonBaloney Lightroom has huge value as a cataloging and organization tool. No plug-in makes that redundant. That said, much of the Nik stuff is superior or equal to the LR stuff, and it is way easier to use. (Which is why Adobe is copying their Nik's awesome control point technology.)
Originally posted by civiletti LR4 is a great cataloging and editing program. The value of NIK plugins for me is the control point function, which allows more selective adjustments. NIK has HDR, which LR4 does not. Viveza 2 is my most used NIK app.
I'm seriously not trying to start any arguements, but just trying to understand the trade-offs between different software.
My perception, right or wrong, is that Nik offers some useful shortcuts in getting to an interesting/attractive image. While Lightroom offers a more manual and comprehensive approach (especially when linked with Photoshop). Nik's point technology seems an awful lot like LR's Adjustment Brush. Sure, in Ver 4, the number of adjustments one could make in that brush have been largely expanded from Ver 3 LR - perhaps in response to Nik's software. One thing for sure, when software brands compete, the customers generally win.
I have to admit enjoying playing with Silver Efex Pro and Color Efex Pro, not sure about what Viveza offers that the former 2 don't, perhaps someone can enlighten me as to what advantages Viveza offers.
I also have the Topaz versions of Nik's plugins and have successfully used it for several pictures that have sold well. LR, Topaz and Nik ALL have localized toning capabilities. The ones in LR and Topaz can be dragged like brushes while the Nik one can't. Yet the Nik implementation of localized toning seems attractive to me and i can't precisely explain why
(Maybe the breakthru concept is to consider points in the picture rather than the dragging more linear process)
A few posts down, some members speculated that Google bought Nik to use their technology on their android smartphones and perhaps tablets. That sounds reasonable to me since it does seem to allow quicker results than other software i have mentioned.
What matters with any software, IMO is whether one gets an end result that they are happy with.