Originally posted by clickclick Reading down this page under the description, it says it has 10 layers -5 each side:
MeFOTO 58mm Wild Blue Yonder Circular Polarizer Filter - Blue Filter Ring MCP58B
Copied from the page above:
Multi-Coated Magic 10 layers. With 5 coatings on each side: this filter has more layers than a chocolate cake! Multi-coating allows maximum light transmission while reducing flare and reflections. Stop defeating your lenses with uncoated camera filters!
I know what it SAYS, but if you have a MeFoto (or Hoya or B+W or...any other) filter, that's multicoated, and look at the reflection of a point source of light in it, the reflection has at least one obvious color cast (green, magenta, blue... something that's extremely obvious.) This CPL absolutely has no color reflection, just like my Tiffen uncoated filters (again, I don't mean to bash Tiffen, when I bought their $7 models I knowingly got what I paid for, I could have bought their $70 models and had multicoating.)
Remember MeFoto is apparently getting out of this business so maybe they had supplier issues or whatever. Just because they box says something doesn't necessarily reflect(!) the product inside.
Incidentally totally off-topic but I always thought it was amazing how back in the 60's before multicoating, all the ads in the camera magazines made those old lenses have multi-coating-like reflections...
Back on track, I've written to MeFoto but since they don't make filters any longer, I'm not holding my breath. And I have to say my application here is for my new-to-me macro lens that I don't use all that often (but really like), and given the choice of multicoating or more transmission, the latter would be my choice (and honestly I'm not paying a lot more to get both for this application.) For my three more often-used lenses I have the B+W XS Pros.
Again I'm not saying it's not got 5 layers of coatings on each side, I'm saying that if it does they aren't traditional AR multicoatings like MeFoto itself uses on the red-ring UV filter I also bought at the same time from Adorama and appears to have also been a good value for the money. The difference in the appearance of the coatings between the two MeFoto filters is like night and day.
I did buy a "multicoated" Vivitar polarizer from another ebay source once and it looked like the MeFoto (in the coatings department - not as nice otherwise and not as high a transmission) and it was horrible. It degraded the images severely on my Tamron 70-300 - again like night and day, unfortunately I only realized it after taking some actual pictures (didn't think I'd need to test a filter.. oh well.) I think that even that filter might have been close to okay at 70mm but I'm going to check out my MeFoto filters just because of that experience.
I'm not an expert but if someone is and knows how to definitively tell (nondestructively!) if the filter has AR coatings, please let us know!