I shoot in RAW and Bibble meets my needs.
My workflow is simple. I briefly review all my photos and give the ones that show potential for sharing or printing a one-star rating. Then I filter the one-star photos and tweak white balance, exposure, sharpening, noise reduction, etc. When I wind up with a keeper I give it a higher rating and maybe add some curves and spot reduction. That's all easy to do with Bibble.
OP, I have no idea how well Bibble plays together with Photoshop. I'm just a hobbyist and haven't invested in PS' learning curve. If my photo is too bad to fix with Bibble, then my lack of Photoshop skills won't be able to save that photo either.
I tested these other photo programs before picking Bibble in January 2011:
- Pentax Digital Camera Utility. Free but criminally unstable. I experienced constant crashes and lost work.
- Lightroom. Seemed functionally equivalent to Bibble. I had no complaints with the trial version but I try to avoid Adobe when practical.
- GIMP. Free. It's an image editor (like PhotoShop) rather than a photo catalog. All those features made it more complex than I need.
- Picasa. Free and easy to use. Not enough features for me. Had some problems with Pentax DNG and PEF formats: odd color casts, thin black bar with spots of color at right edge of photo (I think embedded EXIF data was being interpreted as part of the image).
- DXO. I didn't give this one a fair test because I was already sold on Bibble. It showed potential if I recall correctly.