Originally posted by Pete_XL: I can't say anything to Nebulosity as I use the DeepSkyStacker for stacking and mainly Photoshop afterwards. Usually I equalize and normalize the white point in lightroom in each frame bevor stacking. Often the sky color changes during the the session and DeepSkyStacker sometimes fails if I do not help it. I leave all other settings in LR unchanged and set the already preset sharpening to 0 before I export for stacking. All testing with pre-processing in LR did not result in better stacking results - most were worse.
Sorry, I'm a little confused. You say you eq, norm, etc. in LR before stacking but then you said all testing with pre-processing did not give better results. But you do pre-processing in general or that was a test?
Originally posted by Pete_XL: The big flare I mentioned becomes visible only with maximum stretching in the end of the processing. I can't access your Dropbox from here. If the blue circle is not present in your results you have not stretched it to the maximum extent. I think you should also see it when you apply a maximum contrast in LR by shifting the brighness ruler to the right and then the black one to the left in several consecutive steps.
I tried some more stretching in LR post but can't really see the flair anymore. I think its from the synthetic flattening in Nebulosity - works pretty well but isn't perfect. Anyway, I'll keep an eye on it.
Originally posted by Pete_XL: You conclude in the earlier post above that the vignetting could be an effect of the old lens. All lenses have some amount of vignetting. The 200/4 is not much worse than others. But in AP when stretching the dark part of the histogram to separate background from nebulosity the vignetting effect is multiplied and becomes limiting factor for the processing. I would recommend to use flat frames to correct the image. As you use lenses and not a telescope it should be sufficient to produce and use one master flat for each lens. You can use them in every stacking process to get rid of the vignettes. You can use the "T-Shirt-Method" with two stretched white shirts over the lens that points to the cloudy sky to get the flat data. Using flats is an essential standard in AP. If there remains still some vignetting it can be removed together with other (color) gradients in the beginning of the post processing.
I had flat frames but when I captured, I used pk_tether and the two frame sizes don't match so couldn't use the flats! Its always something! But you make a good case for flats because I was debating about using them and normalization and was ready to ditch both of them. Now that I think of it, maybe I can crop them to match. I'll give that a try.