Studio Tests
"The 10-24mm gives
generally good, if not outstanding results; distortion is well controlled and central sharpness is high once stopped down F5.6, especially at 10mm. However sharpness wide open is distinctly low"
In the Tammy review.
And now the edge part, that they give with a grain of salt, it is in the Sigma's review:
"Compared to the Tamron SP AF 10-24mm F3.5-4.5 Di-II, the Sigma is perhaps starting to show its age; the Tamron is significantly sharper across most of the frame at wideangle, although it has serious problems wide open, and the extreme corners tend to be rather soft. Towards the long end, though, the Sigma edges ahead; but it's probably fair to say that wideangle zooms aren't particularly bought to be used in this range, which is shared with the typical kit zoom. The Sigma also shows notable control of lateral chromatic aberration, but against that the Tamron has significantly lower distortion and falloff. This makes the choice between the two less than entirely clear-cut, however the Tamron probably edges it overall, unless you intend to shoot a lot wide open, or really need the Sigma's HSM focusing."
Then they complicate even more the things saying:
" it simply can't match the biting central sharpness of the Tamron 10-24mm F3.5-4.5 Di-II in the 10-18mm range (for which, we suspect, users will mainly be buying this type of lens), and has more problematic distortion characteristics. However in a typical case of swings and roundabouts, the Sigma shows superior sharpness when shot wide open, and is better in the corners of the frame at all settings; it also has lower chromatic aberration, is better built and uses a superior focusing system"
The thing with the UWA's is that none is a clear victor..all of them have trade-ins (the only one who stands out completely is the Sigma 8-16 and that's just because there is no other option with 8mm!
reviews are fine but acknowledge a fair lot of problems, common to this kind of angle of view).
And they are both recomended by dpreview (the sigma and the tammy...).
And it's hell and back to chose between the two.