I've recently acquired my fourth K-mount 28mm manual lens, an M 28mm f/2.8 version 2 (different optics from the version 1, same optics as the A version) and decided to do a comparison between my manual 28mm lenses, as I have some of what are reputed to be the sharpest K-mount 28mms around. The list is:
I've previously owned a version 1 M 28mm f/2.8 and wasn't impressed by it. My use so far of the second version seems to indicate it's much better.
The M & K f/3.5 lenses have different optical formulae, in case anyone thinks they are the same. The K is (typically for the line) much bigger and heavier than the M.
All my copies of these lenses are in good condition, in fact the three Pentax ones are very close to mint. There's some slight dust in the optics as to be expected for their age, the Vivitar is worst in this regard. I would expect the worst effect of this to be to lower the contrast slightly.
All shots were taken on a K200D (with Katzeye installed) on a tripod at ISO 100, daylight WB, focus at infinity, rubber lens hood, in manual mode and then processed in the Pentax (Silkypix) software. Some adjustment was made to exposure for the first series, but the adjustment was the same for each photo. All other settings were at their default. I would normally add contrast and maybe saturation when using old manual lenses (as I feel they often lack these qualities) but in this case I left them as they are.
The aperture and shutter settings were maintained, except for the Vivitar shot at f/8, where I needed a slower shutter speed to get the same exposure, indicating that the Vivitar lets in less light than the others when stopped down.
I compared the lenses with a wide aperture (f/3.5 for the two slower lenses, f/2.8 for the faster two) and a small aperture (f/8), so there are two shots from each. The full-sized shots are first, followed by 100% crops.
I noticed the dust spot at the top-right when I got home.
1. M28 2.8 vII, f/2.8, 1/2500s
2. M28 2.8 vII, f/8, 1/400s
3. M28 3.5, f/3.5, 1/1600s
4. M28 3.5, f/8, 1/400s
5. K28 3.5, f/3.5, 1/1600s
6. K28 3.5, f/8, 1/400s
7. Vivitar 28 2.0, f/2.8, 1/2500s
8. Vivitar 28 2.0, f/8, 1/250s
Crops (in same order):
1. M28 2.8 vII, f/2.8, 1/2500s
2. M28 2.8 vII, f/8, 1/400s
3. M28 3.5, f/3.5, 1/1600s
4. M28 3.5, f/8, 1/400s
5. K28 3.5, f/3.5, 1/1600s
6. K28 3.5, f/8, 1/400s
7. Vivitar 28 2.0, f/2.8, 1/2500s
8. Vivitar 28 2.0, f/8, 1/250s
The second set I did to give another different comparison shot. These were not shot on a tripod but the other settings were maintained. Focus was on the front wall, but when I went to do the 100% crops I found that sometimes the focus was slightly off, so I didn't bother. At normal viewing sizes they are fine though.
I kept these to wider apertures: f/3.5 for the two slower lenses and f/2.8 & f/4 for the two faster ones.
9. K28 3.5, f/3.5, 1/800s.
10. M28 3.5, f/3.5, 1/800s.
11. M28 2.8 vII, f/2.8, 1/1250s.
12. M28 2.8 vII, f/4, 1/640s.
13. Vivitar 28 2.0, f/2.8, 1/1250s.
14. Vivitar 28 2.0, f/4, 1/640s
Last edited by Jonathan Mac; 07-23-2012 at 12:32 AM.