My collection isn't complete yet, but I thought my set of 5 200mm's would be great for a comparison
Enjoy!
I'm sure the variables in this test aren't perfectly balanced, but I did my best. I'll try again next weeked and we'll see if the results differ at all.
SMC Pentax-A* 200mm F2.8 ED
Handling:
-Loses one point for the weight and lack of a tripod mount
-Built-in hood
Sharpness:
(Rank 3)
-Sharpest at F11, good wide-open
Aberration:
-Loses one point because of slight red fringing (OOF only)
Usefulness:
-F2.8 is good to have, but the fact that it's MF removed the ease of taking sports photos
Overall:
-A great lens for landscapes and close-ups
SMC Pentax-FA* 200mm F2.8 ED [IF]
Handling:
-Very compact. You can take it almost anywhere and fit it in any bag without the hood!
-Loses one point because hood is hard to fit on
Sharpness:
(Rank 2)
-Sharpest at F11, very good wide-open
Aberration:
-Loses one point because of very slight green fringing (OOF & IF)
Usefulness:
-AF makes this lens invaluable for action photography, including birding
Overall:
SMC Pentax-FA* 80-200mm F2.8 ED [IF]
Handling:
-Loses one point because at 3 pounds, it is very hard to hold for extended periods of time. Tripod recommended.
-Loses another point because the hood could be bigger (the hood is designed for the FA* 28-70mm)
-Build-in tripod mount
-Features power zoom and internal zooming
Sharpness:
(Rank 1)
-Very impressive. Sharpest at F8, extremely sharp wide-open.
-Being a zoom, it shouldn't be as sharp as the competition, but it is!
Aberration:
-Virtually nonexistent thanks to the 4 ED elements.
Usefulness:
-Good for almost any purpose! Not recommended for long trips.
Overall:
SMC Pentax-DA 50-200mm F4-5.6 ED
Handling:
-Compact and easy to carry
-No aperture ring. Digital-only
Sharpness:
(Rank 4)
-Sharpest at F11. Not particularly sharp at F5.6.
Aberration:
-Virtually nonexistent!
Usefulness:
-Not the fastest 200mm around.
-Not the best choice for birding or sports photos.
-Ideal for travelling, excels at landscape & close-up photography
Overall:
-An affordable consumer zoom with very high performance!
SMC Pentax-M 200mm F4
Handling:
-Compact and easy to transport.
-Built-in hood
Sharpness:
(Rank 5)
-Unfortunately, this lens doesn't score very high
-Sharpest aperture unknown. Sharp wide-open.
Aberration:
-Lacks ED elements
-Very noticeable green fringing in the OOF area
-Red fringing for items in focus
Usefulness:
-A great tele lens, but it doesn't perform well for close-ups
-Compact yet relatively fast. Could be sharper.
-MF cuts down on possible uses
Overall:
---------------------------
See some of the photos used for this test here:
Pentax 200mm Lens Tests (Note: ignore the A* 200mm shot @ F2.8- I forgot to focus
) (Also note: Some parts of this comparison are based on previous lens use)
Thanks for reading, and please post your thoughts/comments!
Adam
PentaxForums.com Webmaster (
Site Usage Guide |
Site Help |
My Photography)
PentaxForums.com server and development costs are user-supported. You can help cover these costs by
donating or purchasing one of our
Pentax eBooks. Or, buy your photo gear from our affiliates,
Adorama,
B&H Photo,
KEH, or
Topaz Labs, and get
FREE Marketplace access - click here to see how! Trusted Pentax retailers: