I was looking for a good value 200mm+ lens
https://www.pentaxforums.com/forums/pentax-slr-lens-discussion/65237-need-rec...00mm-lens.html
I ended up purchasing a DA 50-200mm lens for a good price here on the marketplace. Not long after, a slew of DA 55-300mm lenses came up here and I decided to pull the trigger on one. I decided to sell the DA 50-200 here to help fund the purchase. But before I sent it off I decided to compare it to the other mid-priced tele-zooms I have on hand:
1. Vivitar S1 70-210 f3.5 (version 1 of this classic lens)
2. Pentax-A 70-210 f4.0
3. DA 50-200mm f4.0-f5.6
4. DA 55-300mm f4.0-f5.8
I had seen comparisons of the the 2 DA's but somehow hadn't seen any comparisons of the 2 MF lenses against each other or against the other 2 AF lenses.
I wanted to compare how they handle, size, weight, and most of all see what I get focal length wise for the DA 55-300 compare to the other 3 zooms I had.
Weight wise here’s how they stacked up, weights are with both caps and hood as applicable:
1. VivS1, v1 963g
2. Pentax-A 694g
3. DA 50-200 306g
4. DA 55-300 484g
You can see the size difference amongst the 4 here along with a Pentax-M 40mm and a Pentax FA 50 f1.4 for scale:
Front Row: Pentax-M 40mm f2.8, Pentax FA 50 f1.4
Back Row, L to R: 18-55 DA AL II kit lens, DA 50-200, DA 55-300, Pentax-A 70-210, Vivitar Series 1 70-210 f3.5 (Version 1)
Lens 1 & 2 obviously are MF with the Pentax-A being easier to use due to its K-A mount. Also, the Pentax-A is much easier to handle due to it’s smaller size and weight. Vivitar is 1/3 stop faster, however at a size/weight penalty. If I had to choose which of these 2 to keep, I would probably give up the 1/3 stop and choose the Pentax-A due to its handling ease. IQ wise, for my purposes I’d call it a wash since the largest I’d print would probably be 8x10 prints and more than likely I’d probably view these on a monitor rather than prints. However, maybe you folks here can tell me which one is better IQ wise based on the quick shots I took (which I’ll post later). In terms of price between the 2 MF I would probably price the Pentax-A higher since not only can I use all metering modes with it but I can also use my AF360 in P-TTL. Price for these 2 in the current market is probably all over the map. The VivS1 is one of those cult classics and its value is also up there due to its construction and reputation.
I'll continue later with my impressions of the 2 AF lenses, so to be continued.....
Last edited by PentHassyKon; 08-04-2009 at 09:50 AM.