@lidy First cab off the rank and has chosen to remove excess elements in the frame that can distract from the primary subject. I like the choice to line the edge of the concrete section to the corner too. The choice of complimentary colours is clear to see, and I particularly like the detail and light captured on the wet concrete surfaces.

@gareme83 This styilsed version appears to have a 4:5 framing, a framing style I use quite often. The concrete edge again lines up with the corner of the frame. The light and dark areas of this image have been created to emphasise parts of the frame it appears, with warmer tones and a filmic quality that works a treat.

@Arjay Bee The whole of the frame was retained in this lighter brighter version that to me seems to draw out the subtlety of the warm light on the horizon and reflected in the wet concrete in front of our subject. The expansiveness of the wide angle lens is here for all to see and I must say, I am a big cloud fan.

@mariwalt A stronger crop in this version locks us onto our fisherman with stronger contrast capturing the detail in the person and really highlighting the aged surfaces in the concrete section where our fisherman is standing. The grey clouds look great including the lighter clouds off in the distance all showing the turbulent sky.

@bertwert I like the pano framing, for isolation from the heavier sky changing the feel of this scene to what could be a pleasant afternoon fish with a setting sun in the distance. The exposure of the surfaces and our subject looks spot on and very natural.

@noelcmn Three versions created here all with different framing. The strong crop in image number 1 seems to tell a tale of a man taking on the sea. There's a hint of menace created with the darker exposure being retained. The strong green is otherworldly in version 2 the turquoise tones seems to highlight the warmth in the sky on the horizon and is enhanced with this choice. The final black and white image has our fisherman, like in image 2, more a part of a larger world and what is happening around him. This image is like an early morning fisherman you might come across alone until you arrive with your camera.

@tuggie76 Like an onion, layers can be the key to some PP magic. What's ironic is the dolphins added are close to a placed called the Cowrie Hole, a surfing spot regularly accessed by surfers who jump in off to the right of where our fisherman is in the frame. Some subtle warm tones here create a different look to the scene highlighting detail in the wet concrete but more importantly really creating some magic in the sky on the horizon.

@jmacais A vertical framing and overall lighter scene making the warm sky impressive and contrasting with the neutral grey clouds in the distance. The brighter exposure choice makes this seem closer to the middle of the day at the time of capture.

@astonm Purple worked for Prince, right? Good use of rule of thirds for our Fisherman, he anchors the frame nicely. The green wall is really drawn out in contrast with the magenta sky, with an overall warm feel to the tones in the sky and on the concrete surface. Very natural sharpening/contrast too.

@graeme83 Back for a final version and a square frame of the scene. Always good to see. This version has the similar heavy clouds to the version created earlier with strong contrast from the background sky pointing to an approaching storm. This same strong black versus white works a treat due to the railings and concrete being emphasised and highlighting how it frames our subject.